4 12 Politics Politic NNP 12 13 , , , 14 17 not not RB 18 21 the the DT 22 33 environment environment NN 33 34 , , , 35 41 drives drive VBZ 42 47 Kyoto Kyoto NNP 53 59 Author author NN 59 60 : : : 65 70 Barry Barry NNP 71 77 Cooper Cooper NNP 78 81 and and CC 82 87 David David NNP 88 96 Bercuson Bercuson NNP 100 103 The the DT 104 108 only only JJ 109 116 winners winner NNS 117 119 in in IN 120 123 the the DT 124 136 increasingly increasingly RB 137 143 heated heated JJ 144 150 debate debate NN 151 155 over over IN 156 162 global global JJ 164 171 warming warming NN 172 175 are be VBP 176 179 the the DT 180 187 boffins boffin NNS 188 190 in in IN 191 197 Ottawa Ottawa NNP 197 198 . . . 199 200 A a DT 201 207 couple couple NN 208 210 of of IN 211 216 weeks week NNS 217 220 ago ago RB 220 221 , , , 222 225 the the DT 227 234 federal federal JJ 235 245 government government NN 246 257 distributed distribute VBD 258 259 a a DT 260 269 colourful colourful JJ 270 282 announcement announcement NN 283 285 in in IN 287 297 newspapers newspaper NNS 298 304 across across IN 305 308 the the DT 309 313 land land NN 314 325 proclaiming proclaim VBG 326 330 that that IN 331 332 “ `` `` 332 335 the the DT 336 341 Earth Earth NNP 342 344 is be VBZ 346 353 getting get VBG 354 360 warmer warmer NN 360 361 ” '' '' 362 365 and and CC 366 370 that that IN 371 383 implementing implement VBG 384 387 the the DT 388 392 1997 1997 CD 393 398 Kyoto Kyoto NNP 399 407 Protocol Protocol NNP 407 408 , , , 410 412 on on IN 413 416 the the DT 417 425 targeted target VBN 426 435 reduction reduction NN 436 438 of of IN 439 448 so-called so-called JJ 449 459 greenhouse greenhouse NN 460 465 gases gas NNS 465 466 , , , 467 472 would would MD 474 477 fix fix VB 478 484 things thing NNS 484 485 . . . 489 492 Ten ten CD 493 497 days day NNS 498 501 ago ago RB 501 502 , , , 503 507 when when WRB 508 513 asked ask VBN 514 519 about about IN 520 525 Kyoto Kyoto NNP 526 528 at at IN 529 532 the the DT 533 536 now now RB 537 543 famous famous JJ 544 548 Team Team NNP 550 556 Canada Canada NNP 557 562 press press NN 563 573 conference conference NN 574 576 in in IN 577 583 Moscow Moscow NNP 583 584 , , , 585 592 Premier Premier NNP 593 598 Ralph Ralph NNP 599 604 Klein Klein NNP 605 613 produced produce VBD 615 616 a a DT 617 623 letter letter NN 624 634 indicating indicate VBG 635 639 that that IN 640 643 all all PDT 644 647 the the DT 648 656 premiers premier NNS 656 657 , , , 658 664 except except IN 665 668 the the DT 670 683 ever-distinct ever-distinct JJ 684 690 Quebec Quebec NNP 690 691 , , , 692 699 opposed oppose VBD 700 705 Kyoto Kyoto NNP 705 706 . . . 707 708 A a DT 709 712 few few JJ 713 717 days day NNS 718 723 later later RB 724 726 in in IN 727 733 Munich Munich NNP 733 734 , , , 736 746 provincial provincial JJ 747 757 opposition opposition NN 758 761 was be VBD 762 768 hedged hedge VBN 769 773 with with IN 774 788 qualifications qualification NNS 788 789 : : : 790 793 The the DT 794 797 NDP NDP NNP 799 807 premiers premier NNS 808 810 of of IN 811 823 Saskatchewan Saskatchewan NNP 824 827 and and CC 828 836 Manitoba Manitoba NNP 837 847 apparently apparently RB 848 855 thought think VBD 856 859 the the DT 861 862 “ `` `` 862 872 principles principle NNS 872 873 ” '' '' 874 876 of of IN 877 882 Kyoto Kyoto NNP 883 887 were be VBD 888 892 fine fine JJ 892 893 . . . 894 898 They they PRP 899 903 just just RB 904 910 wanted want VBD 911 915 more more JJR 917 930 consultations consultation NNS 930 931 . . . 935 939 Herb Herb NNP 940 948 Dhaliwal Dhaliwal NNP 948 949 , , , 950 953 the the DT 954 961 federal federal JJ 962 968 Energy Energy NNP 969 977 Minister Minister NNP 977 978 , , , 979 986 weighed weigh VBD 987 989 in in RP 990 994 with with IN 995 999 even even RB 1001 1005 more more JJR 1006 1020 qualifications qualification NNS 1020 1021 : : : 1022 1023 “ `` `` 1023 1027 Some some DT 1028 1037 important important JJ 1038 1045 details detail NNS 1046 1050 have have VBP 1051 1053 to to TO 1054 1056 be be VB 1057 1063 worked work VBN 1065 1068 out out RP 1069 1075 before before IN 1076 1082 Canada Canada NNP 1083 1091 ratifies ratify VBZ 1092 1095 the the DT 1096 1101 Kyoto Kyoto NNP 1102 1110 Protocol Protocol NNP 1110 1111 , , , 1111 1112 ” '' '' 1113 1115 he he PRP 1116 1120 said say VBD 1120 1121 . . . 1122 1123 “ `` `` 1123 1124 I I PRP 1126 1131 would would MD 1131 1134 n’t n't RB 1135 1139 sign sign VB 1140 1141 a a DT 1142 1150 contract contract NN 1151 1153 in in IN 1154 1162 business business NN 1163 1169 unless unless IN 1170 1171 I I PRP 1172 1176 knew know VBD 1177 1184 exactly exactly RB 1185 1189 what what WP 1191 1193 it it PRP 1194 1199 meant mean VBD 1199 1200 . . . 1200 1201 ” '' '' 1202 1205 His his PRP$ 1206 1210 boss boss NN 1211 1221 apparently apparently RB 1222 1225 has have VBZ 1226 1230 less less JJR 1231 1239 business business NN 1240 1245 sense sense NN 1245 1246 . . . 1248 1257 According accord VBG 1258 1260 to to TO 1261 1265 Jean Jean NNP 1266 1274 Chretien Chretien NNP 1274 1275 , , , 1276 1277 “ `` `` 1277 1280 the the DT 1281 1287 desire desire NN 1288 1290 of of IN 1291 1294 the the DT 1295 1302 federal federal JJ 1304 1314 government government NN 1315 1317 is be VBZ 1318 1320 to to TO 1321 1325 sign sign VB 1326 1328 it it PRP 1328 1329 . . . 1329 1330 ” '' '' 1334 1341 Another another DT 1342 1346 sign sign NN 1347 1350 the the DT 1351 1357 debate debate NN 1358 1360 is be VBZ 1361 1373 intensifying intensify VBG 1374 1381 emerged emerge VBN 1382 1386 last last JJ 1387 1391 week week NN 1392 1394 at at IN 1395 1396 a a DT 1398 1404 global global JJ 1405 1412 warming warm VBG 1413 1423 conference conference NN 1424 1426 in in IN 1427 1433 Ottawa Ottawa NNP 1433 1434 . . . 1435 1440 Lorne Lorne NNP 1441 1447 Taylor Taylor NNP 1447 1448 , , , 1449 1452 the the DT 1453 1460 Alberta Alberta NNP 1462 1473 Environment Environment NNP 1474 1482 Minister Minister NNP 1482 1483 , , , 1484 1493 estimated estimate VBD 1494 1497 the the DT 1498 1503 costs cost NNS 1504 1506 of of IN 1507 1512 Kyoto Kyoto NNP 1513 1515 to to TO 1516 1519 the the DT 1521 1529 Canadian canadian JJ 1530 1537 economy economy NN 1538 1540 to to TO 1541 1543 be be VB 1544 1553 somewhere somewhere RB 1554 1561 between between IN 1562 1563 $ $ $ 1563 1573 25-billion 25-billion CD 1574 1577 and and CC 1579 1580 $ $ $ 1580 1590 40-billion 40-billion CD 1591 1592 a a DT 1593 1597 year year NN 1597 1598 . . . 1599 1601 It it PRP 1602 1607 would would MD 1608 1612 cost cost VB 1613 1620 Alberta Alberta NNP 1621 1630 somewhere somewhere RB 1631 1638 between between IN 1640 1641 $ $ $ 1641 1650 3-billion 3-billion CD 1651 1654 and and CC 1655 1656 $ $ $ 1656 1665 6-billion 6-billion CD 1665 1666 . . . 1667 1673 Taylor Taylor NNP 1674 1678 told tell VBD 1679 1682 his his PRP$ 1683 1689 Quebec Quebec NNP 1690 1697 critics critic NNS 1698 1702 that that IN 1704 1708 they they PRP 1709 1715 should should MD 1716 1718 be be VB 1719 1723 more more RBR 1724 1735 circumspect circumspect JJ 1735 1736 . . . 1737 1738 “ `` `` 1738 1742 They they PRP 1743 1748 stand stand VBP 1749 1753 with with IN 1754 1759 empty empty JJ 1760 1767 pockets pocket NNS 1769 1772 and and CC 1773 1778 their their PRP$ 1779 1784 hands hand NNS 1785 1790 empty empty JJ 1790 1791 , , , 1792 1795 out out IN 1796 1802 toward toward IN 1803 1810 Alberta Alberta NNP 1810 1811 , , , 1812 1815 and and CC 1816 1818 at at IN 1819 1822 the the DT 1823 1827 same same JJ 1828 1832 time time NN 1834 1838 they they PRP 1838 1841 ’re 're VBP 1842 1853 criticizing criticize VBG 1854 1861 Alberta Alberta NNP 1861 1862 . . . 1862 1863 ” '' '' 1864 1866 He he PRP 1867 1870 was be VBD 1871 1879 alluding allude VBG 1880 1882 to to TO 1883 1886 the the DT 1887 1892 great great JJ 1893 1898 money money NN 1900 1910 laundering launder VBG 1911 1920 operation operation NN 1921 1928 whereby whereby WRB 1929 1932 the the DT 1933 1940 federal federal JJ 1941 1951 government government NN 1952 1961 transfers transfer VBZ 1963 1967 cash cash NN 1968 1972 from from IN 1973 1983 productive productive JJ 1984 1993 provinces province NNS 1994 1998 such such JJ 1999 2001 as as IN 2002 2009 Alberta Alberta NNP 2010 2013 and and CC 2014 2023 dispenses dispense VBZ 2024 2026 it it PRP 2028 2030 in in IN 2031 2037 places place NNS 2038 2042 such such JJ 2043 2045 as as IN 2046 2052 Quebec Quebec NNP 2052 2053 . . . 2057 2059 At at IN 2060 2063 the the DT 2064 2068 same same JJ 2069 2079 conference conference NN 2079 2080 , , , 2081 2087 Taylor Taylor NNP 2087 2089 ’s 's POS 2090 2097 federal federal JJ 2098 2109 counterpart counterpart NN 2109 2110 , , , 2111 2116 David David NNP 2118 2126 Anderson Anderson NNP 2126 2127 , , , 2128 2137 announced announce VBD 2138 2142 that that IN 2143 2146 the the DT 2147 2154 Alberta Alberta NNP 2155 2162 numbers number NNS 2163 2167 were be VBD 2168 2174 absurd absurd JJ 2174 2175 . . . 2177 2189 Implementing implement VBG 2190 2195 Kyoto Kyoto NNP 2196 2201 would would MD 2202 2206 cost cost VB 2207 2208 a a DT 2209 2215 paltry paltry JJ 2216 2217 $ $ $ 2217 2228 500-million 500-million CD 2228 2229 , , , 2230 2232 he he PRP 2233 2237 said say VBD 2237 2238 , , , 2240 2243 and and CC 2244 2249 added add VBD 2250 2254 more more RBR 2255 2264 ominously ominously RB 2265 2269 that that IN 2270 2271 “ `` `` 2271 2274 the the DT 2275 2280 issue issue NN 2280 2281 , , , 2282 2293 technically technically RB 2293 2294 , , , 2295 2297 is be VBZ 2298 2302 that that IN 2304 2317 international international JJ 2318 2327 relations relation NNS 2328 2332 fall fall VBP 2333 2339 within within IN 2340 2343 the the DT 2344 2351 purview purview NN 2352 2354 of of IN 2355 2358 the the DT 2359 2366 federal federal JJ 2368 2378 government government NN 2378 2379 . . . 2380 2383 And and CC 2384 2386 it it PRP 2387 2390 can can MD 2391 2394 act act VB 2395 2407 unilaterally unilaterally RB 2407 2408 . . . 2408 2409 ” '' '' 2413 2418 There there EX 2419 2422 are be VBP 2423 2426 two two CD 2427 2433 levels level NNS 2434 2436 to to TO 2437 2440 the the DT 2441 2452 controversy controversy NN 2453 2459 around around IN 2460 2465 Kyoto Kyoto NNP 2465 2466 . . . 2467 2470 The the DT 2471 2476 first first JJ 2476 2477 , , , 2479 2481 as as IN 2482 2485 the the DT 2486 2493 numbers number NNS 2494 2500 tossed toss VBD 2501 2506 about about RP 2507 2509 by by IN 2510 2516 Taylor Taylor NNP 2517 2520 and and CC 2521 2529 Anderson Anderson NNP 2530 2538 indicate indicate VBP 2538 2539 , , , 2540 2542 is be VBZ 2544 2551 centred centre VBN 2552 2554 on on IN 2555 2560 costs cost NNS 2561 2563 of of IN 2564 2574 compliance compliance NN 2574 2575 . . . 2576 2585 Canadians Canadian NNPS 2586 2590 know know VBP 2590 2591 , , , 2592 2596 with with IN 2597 2598 a a DT 2599 2608 certainty certainty NN 2610 2621 approaching approach VBG 2622 2632 perfection perfection NN 2632 2633 , , , 2634 2638 that that IN 2639 2642 the the DT 2643 2650 federal federal JJ 2651 2661 government government NN 2662 2664 is be VBZ 2666 2677 incompetent incompetent JJ 2678 2682 when when WRB 2683 2685 it it PRP 2686 2691 comes come VBZ 2692 2694 to to TO 2695 2703 offering offer VBG 2704 2708 even even RB 2709 2727 order-of-magnitude order-of-magnitude JJ 2729 2736 guesses guess NNS 2736 2737 . . . 2738 2741 The the DT 2742 2745 gun gun NN 2746 2758 registration registration NN 2759 2766 program program NN 2767 2773 proves prove VBZ 2774 2778 this this DT 2779 2785 beyond beyond IN 2786 2789 the the DT 2791 2797 shadow shadow NN 2798 2800 of of IN 2801 2802 a a DT 2803 2808 doubt doubt NN 2808 2809 . . . 2813 2819 Taylor Taylor NNP 2820 2823 may may MD 2824 2828 have have VB 2829 2836 offered offer VBN 2837 2838 a a DT 2839 2843 more more RBR 2844 2851 prudent prudent JJ 2852 2857 guess guess NN 2857 2858 , , , 2859 2862 but but CC 2863 2866 the the DT 2867 2871 fact fact NN 2872 2874 is be VBZ 2874 2875 , , , 2877 2885 accurate accurate JJ 2886 2895 estimates estimate NNS 2896 2898 of of IN 2899 2902 the the DT 2903 2908 costs cost NNS 2909 2911 of of IN 2912 2920 policies policy NNS 2921 2929 designed design VBN 2930 2932 to to TO 2933 2939 reduce reduce VB 2941 2949 selected select VBN 2950 2953 gas gas NN 2954 2963 emissions emission NNS 2964 2967 are be VBP 2968 2978 impossible impossible JJ 2978 2979 . . . 2980 2982 No no DT 2983 2986 one one NN 2987 2992 knows know VBZ 2993 2996 the the DT 2997 3003 impact impact NN 3005 3007 on on IN 3008 3014 Canada Canada NNP 3014 3016 ’s 's POS 3017 3030 international international JJ 3031 3046 competitiveness competitiveness NN 3046 3047 , , , 3048 3052 when when WRB 3053 3058 China China NNP 3058 3059 , , , 3060 3065 India India NNP 3065 3066 , , , 3068 3074 Brazil Brazil NNP 3074 3075 , , , 3076 3079 and and CC 3080 3089 Indonesia Indonesia NNP 3090 3093 are be VBP 3094 3097 not not RB 3098 3107 committed commit VBN 3108 3110 to to TO 3111 3117 reduce reduce VB 3118 3126 anything anything NN 3126 3127 . . . 3128 3130 No no DT 3132 3135 one one NN 3136 3139 can can MD 3140 3148 estimate estimate VB 3149 3152 the the DT 3153 3158 costs cost NNS 3159 3161 or or CC 3162 3170 benefits benefit NNS 3171 3173 of of IN 3174 3184 developing develop VBG 3185 3190 novel novel JJ 3192 3198 energy energy NN 3199 3206 sources source NNS 3207 3214 because because IN 3214 3215 , , , 3216 3218 if if IN 3219 3222 new new JJ 3223 3232 knowledge knowledge NN 3233 3238 could could MD 3239 3241 be be VB 3242 3247 known know VBN 3248 3250 in in IN 3252 3259 advance advance NN 3259 3260 , , , 3261 3263 it it PRP 3264 3269 would would MD 3269 3272 n’t n't RB 3273 3275 be be VB 3276 3279 new new JJ 3279 3280 . . . 3284 3294 Underlying underlie VBG 3295 3298 the the DT 3299 3312 uncertainties uncertainty NNS 3313 3322 regarding regard VBG 3323 3328 costs cost NNS 3329 3332 are be VBP 3333 3337 more more RBR 3339 3350 fundamental fundamental JJ 3351 3364 uncertainties uncertainty NNS 3365 3370 about about IN 3371 3374 the the DT 3375 3385 scientific scientific JJ 3386 3394 evidence evidence NN 3394 3395 . . . 3399 3401 To to TO 3402 3407 begin begin VB 3408 3412 with with IN 3412 3413 , , , 3414 3419 there there EX 3420 3423 are be VBP 3424 3429 major major JJ 3430 3441 measurement measurement NN 3442 3450 problems problem NNS 3450 3451 . . . 3453 3465 Historically historically RB 3465 3466 , , , 3467 3473 nearly nearly RB 3474 3477 all all DT 3478 3489 temperature temperature NN 3490 3494 data datum NNS 3495 3499 have have VBP 3500 3504 been be VBN 3505 3514 collected collect VBN 3516 3520 from from IN 3521 3522 “ `` `` 3522 3527 urban urban JJ 3528 3532 heat heat NN 3533 3540 islands island NNS 3540 3541 ” '' '' 3542 3545 and and CC 3545 3546 , , , 3547 3549 as as IN 3550 3553 New New NNP 3554 3561 Zealand Zealand NNP 3562 3575 climatologist climatologist NN 3577 3584 Vincent Vincent NNP 3585 3589 Gray Gray NNP 3590 3598 observed observe VBD 3598 3599 , , , 3600 3601 “ `` `` 3601 3604 all all DT 3605 3617 measurements measurement NNS 3618 3620 of of IN 3621 3627 global global JJ 3628 3639 temperature temperature NN 3641 3645 that that WDT 3646 3649 are be VBP 3650 3654 made make VBN 3655 3658 far far RB 3659 3663 from from IN 3664 3669 human human JJ 3670 3680 habitation habitation NN 3681 3685 show show VBP 3686 3688 no no DT 3689 3693 sign sign NN 3694 3696 of of IN 3697 3700 any any DT 3702 3709 warming warming NN 3709 3710 . . . 3710 3711 ” '' '' 3715 3721 Second second RB 3721 3722 , , , 3723 3728 there there EX 3729 3731 is be VBZ 3732 3734 no no DT 3735 3743 evidence evidence NN 3744 3746 on on IN 3747 3750 the the DT 3751 3754 net net JJ 3755 3761 impact impact NN 3762 3764 of of IN 3765 3770 human human JJ 3772 3780 activity activity NN 3780 3781 . . . 3782 3786 Last last JJ 3787 3793 spring spring NN 3794 3797 the the DT 3798 3806 American American NNP 3807 3815 National National NNP 3816 3823 Academy Academy NNP 3824 3826 of of IN 3827 3834 Science Science NNP 3836 3842 warned warn VBD 3843 3847 that that IN 3848 3855 because because IN 3856 3857 “ `` `` 3857 3862 there there EX 3863 3865 is be VBZ 3866 3878 considerable considerable JJ 3879 3890 uncertainty uncertainty NN 3891 3893 in in IN 3895 3902 current current JJ 3903 3916 understanding understanding NN 3917 3919 of of IN 3920 3923 how how WRB 3924 3927 the the DT 3928 3935 climate climate NN 3936 3942 system system NN 3943 3949 varies vary VBZ 3951 3960 naturally naturally RB 3960 3961 , , , 3961 3962 ” '' '' 3963 3966 any any DT 3967 3976 estimates estimate NNS 3977 3979 of of IN 3980 3986 either either CC 3987 3990 the the DT 3991 4000 magnitude magnitude NN 4001 4003 or or CC 4004 4007 the the DT 4009 4018 direction direction NN 4019 4021 of of IN 4022 4028 future future JJ 4029 4036 warming warming NN 4037 4041 must must MD 4042 4044 be be VB 4045 4051 highly highly RB 4052 4061 tentative tentative JJ 4061 4062 . . . 4066 4073 Finally finally RB 4073 4074 , , , 4075 4079 vast vast JJ 4080 4091 uncertainty uncertainty NN 4092 4094 is be VBZ 4095 4100 built build VBN 4101 4105 into into IN 4106 4114 computer computer NN 4115 4121 models model NNS 4122 4124 of of IN 4126 4133 climate climate JJ 4134 4140 change change NN 4140 4141 . . . 4142 4145 The the DT 4146 4150 best good JJS 4151 4157 models model NNS 4158 4163 today today NN 4164 4168 dice dice VBP 4169 4172 the the DT 4173 4183 atmosphere atmosphere NN 4184 4188 into into IN 4189 4190 a a DT 4192 4202 collection collection NN 4203 4205 of of IN 4206 4213 virtual virtual JJ 4214 4219 cubes cube NNS 4220 4225 about about IN 4226 4229 185 185 CD 4230 4235 miles mile NNS 4236 4238 on on IN 4239 4240 a a DT 4241 4245 side side NN 4245 4246 . . . 4247 4254 Because because IN 4256 4258 of of IN 4259 4262 the the DT 4263 4280 three-dimensional three-dimensional JJ 4281 4287 nature nature NN 4288 4290 of of IN 4291 4294 the the DT 4295 4302 problem problem NN 4302 4303 , , , 4304 4312 doubling double VBG 4313 4316 the the DT 4318 4328 resolution resolution NN 4329 4337 requires require VBZ 4338 4340 16 16 CD 4341 4346 times time NNS 4347 4350 the the DT 4351 4359 computer computer NN 4360 4365 power power NN 4365 4366 . . . 4367 4369 To to TO 4370 4373 get get VB 4374 4377 the the DT 4379 4384 cubes cube NNS 4385 4389 down down RP 4390 4392 to to TO 4393 4394 a a DT 4395 4401 useful useful JJ 4402 4406 size size NN 4407 4409 – -- : 4410 4416 around around IN 4417 4419 20 20 CD 4420 4425 miles mile NNS 4426 4427 a a DT 4428 4432 side side NN 4433 4435 – -- : 4436 4441 would would MD 4443 4447 take take VB 4448 4457 computers computer NNS 4458 4463 about about IN 4464 4469 1,000 1,000 CD 4470 4475 times time NNS 4476 4478 as as RB 4479 4487 powerful powerful JJ 4488 4490 as as IN 4491 4494 are be VBP 4495 4504 currently currently RB 4506 4515 available available JJ 4515 4516 . . . 4520 4524 Even even RB 4525 4527 if if IN 4528 4532 they they PRP 4533 4540 existed exist VBD 4540 4541 , , , 4542 4547 there there EX 4548 4550 is be VBZ 4551 4553 no no DT 4554 4562 reliable reliable JJ 4563 4571 baseline baseline NN 4572 4576 from from IN 4577 4582 which which WDT 4584 4586 to to TO 4587 4592 begin begin VB 4592 4593 : : : 4594 4596 No no DT 4597 4600 one one NN 4601 4606 knows know VBZ 4607 4611 what what WP 4612 4618 global global JJ 4619 4626 weather weather NN 4627 4630 was be VBD 4631 4637 really really RB 4638 4642 like like IN 4643 4645 in in IN 4647 4651 1900 1900 CD 4652 4654 or or CC 4655 4659 1850 1850 CD 4660 4662 to to TO 4663 4666 say say VB 4667 4674 nothing nothing NN 4675 4677 of of IN 4678 4685 earlier early JJR 4686 4691 dates date NNS 4691 4692 . . . 4693 4695 In in IN 4696 4701 short short JJ 4701 4702 , , , 4703 4710 because because IN 4712 4715 the the DT 4716 4725 estimates estimate NNS 4726 4728 of of IN 4729 4732 the the DT 4733 4738 scale scale NN 4739 4742 and and CC 4743 4749 timing timing NN 4750 4752 of of IN 4753 4764 atmospheric atmospheric JJ 4765 4772 warming warming NN 4773 4776 are be VBP 4778 4780 so so RB 4781 4790 uncertain uncertain JJ 4790 4791 , , , 4792 4794 it it PRP 4795 4797 is be VBZ 4798 4802 just just RB 4803 4806 not not RB 4807 4815 possible possible JJ 4816 4818 to to TO 4819 4825 assess assess VB 4826 4829 the the DT 4830 4835 costs cost NNS 4836 4839 and and CC 4841 4849 benefits benefit NNS 4849 4850 . . . 4851 4854 The the DT 4855 4859 fact fact NN 4860 4862 is be VBZ 4862 4863 , , , 4864 4869 Kyoto Kyoto NNP 4870 4872 is be VBZ 4873 4880 without without IN 4881 4891 principles principle NNS 4892 4895 and and CC 4896 4898 no no DT 4899 4902 one one NN 4904 4907 has have VBZ 4908 4909 a a DT 4910 4914 clue clue NN 4915 4919 what what WP 4920 4922 it it PRP 4923 4928 means mean VBZ 4928 4929 . . . 4933 4935 As as IN 4936 4937 a a DT 4938 4949 consequence consequence NN 4949 4950 , , , 4951 4955 only only RB 4956 4959 the the DT 4960 4968 politics politic NNS 4969 4971 of of IN 4972 4977 Kyoto Kyoto NNP 4978 4983 count count NN 4983 4984 . . . 4985 4993 Swelling swell VBG 4994 4997 the the DT 4999 5009 population population NN 5010 5012 of of IN 5013 5024 envirocrats envirocrat NNS 5025 5027 in in IN 5028 5034 Ottawa Ottawa NNP 5035 5040 means mean VBZ 5041 5045 that that IN 5046 5049 the the DT 5050 5054 sole sole JJ 5056 5067 beneficiary beneficiary NN 5068 5070 is be VBZ 5071 5074 the the DT 5075 5082 federal federal JJ 5083 5093 government government NN 5093 5094 . . . 5095 5103 Everyone everyone NN 5104 5108 else else RB 5109 5114 loses lose VBZ 5114 5115 . . . 5119 5128 Copyright copyright NN 5129 5130 @ @ , 5131 5135 2002 2002 CD 5136 5144 National National NNP 5145 5149 Post Post NNP 5150 5156 Online Online NNP 5157 5158 | | .