2 5 The the DT 6 10 U.S. U.S. NNP 11 21 government government NN 22 26 says say VBZ 27 31 that that IN 32 35 the the DT 36 45 terrorist terrorist JJ 46 52 attack attack NN 53 55 on on IN 56 59 New New NNP 60 64 York York NNP 65 69 City City NNP 70 73 was be VBD 74 76 an an DT 77 80 act act NN 81 83 of of IN 84 87 war war NN 87 88 . . . 89 92 Yet yet CC 93 95 it it PRP 96 103 refuses refuse VBZ 104 106 to to TO 107 112 treat treat VB 113 118 those those DT 119 121 it it PRP 122 125 has have VBZ 126 134 captured capture VBN 135 137 in in IN 138 141 the the DT 142 148 course course NN 149 151 of of IN 152 156 this this DT 157 160 war war NN 161 163 as as IN 164 173 prisoners prisoner NNS 174 176 of of IN 177 180 war war NN 180 181 . . . 182 189 Instead instead RB 189 190 , , , 191 193 it it PRP 194 200 refers refer VBZ 201 203 to to TO 204 208 them them PRP 209 211 as as IN 212 213 “ `` `` 213 221 unlawful unlawful JJ 222 232 combatants combatant NNS 232 233 ” '' '' 234 237 not not RB 238 246 entitled entitle VBN 247 249 to to TO 250 253 the the DT 254 264 protection protection NN 265 267 of of IN 268 271 the the DT 272 276 1949 1949 CD 277 283 Geneva Geneva NNP 284 294 Convention Convention NNP 294 295 , , , 296 301 which which WDT 302 305 the the DT 306 310 U.S. U.S. NNP 311 317 signed sign VBN 318 321 and and CC 322 327 which which WDT 328 332 sets set VBZ 333 336 out out RP 337 342 rules rule NNS 343 346 for for IN 347 355 treating treat VBG 356 361 enemy enemy NN 362 370 soldiers soldier NNS 370 371 . . . 372 374 It it PRP 375 383 shackles shackle VBZ 384 388 them them PRP 388 389 , , , 390 396 houses house VBZ 397 401 them them PRP 402 404 in in IN 405 416 unprotected unprotected JJ 417 422 chain chain NN 423 427 link link NN 428 437 compounds compound NNS 438 439 ( ( ( 439 441 in in IN 442 446 Cuba Cuba NNP 446 447 , , , 448 450 of of IN 451 454 all all DT 455 461 places place NNS 461 462 ) ) ) 463 466 and and CC 467 476 threatens threaten VBZ 477 478 “ `` `` 478 485 intense intense JJ 486 499 interrogation interrogation NN 499 500 . . . 500 501 ” '' '' 508 512 This this DT 513 516 may may MD 517 519 be be VB 520 530 convenient convenient JJ 531 534 for for IN 535 545 Washington Washington NNP 545 546 . . . 547 550 But but CC 551 553 it it PRP 554 558 sets set VBZ 559 560 a a DT 561 570 dangerous dangerous JJ 571 580 precedent precedent NN 581 584 for for IN 585 588 all all DT 589 597 soldiers soldier NNS 598 601 who who WP 602 606 face face VBP 607 614 capture capture NN 615 617 in in IN 618 621 the the DT 622 631 so-called so-called JJ 632 635 war war NN 636 638 on on IN 639 648 terrorism terrorism NN 648 649 , , , 650 659 including include VBG 660 666 Canada Canada NNP 666 668 ’s 's POS 668 669 . . . 676 683 Perhaps perhaps RB 684 686 it it PRP 687 689 is be VBZ 690 698 perverse perverse JJ 699 701 to to TO 702 706 have have VB 707 712 rules rule NNS 713 716 for for IN 717 724 warfare warfare NN 724 725 . . . 726 729 But but CC 730 733 the the DT 734 739 world world NN 740 742 is be VBZ 743 744 a a DT 745 753 perverse perverse JJ 754 759 place place NN 759 760 . . . 761 764 And and CC 765 767 so so RB 767 768 , , , 769 774 since since IN 775 778 the the DT 779 783 late late JJ 784 788 19th 19th JJ 789 796 century century NN 796 797 , , , 798 802 most most JJS 803 810 nations nation NNS 811 815 that that WDT 816 820 call call VBP 821 831 themselves themselves PRP 832 841 civilized civilize VBN 842 846 have have VBP 847 854 adhered adhere VBN 855 857 to to TO 858 862 such such JJ 863 868 rules rule NNS 868 869 . . . 870 873 The the DT 874 878 1949 1949 CD 879 885 Geneva Geneva NNP 886 896 Convention Convention NNP 897 906 specifies specify VBZ 907 911 that that IN 912 915 any any DT 916 928 belligerents belligerent NNS 929 937 captured capture VBN 938 940 in in IN 941 944 the the DT 945 951 course course NN 952 954 of of IN 955 958 war war NN 959 960 - - HYPH 961 963 be be VB 964 968 they they PRP 969 976 regular regular JJ 977 985 soldiers soldier NNS 985 986 , , , 987 994 militia militia NN 995 1002 members member NNS 1003 1005 or or CC 1006 1016 volunteers volunteer NNS 1017 1018 “ `` `` 1018 1027 operating operate VBG 1028 1030 in in IN 1031 1033 or or CC 1034 1041 outside outside IN 1042 1047 their their PRP$ 1048 1057 territory territory NN 1058 1062 even even RB 1063 1065 if if IN 1066 1070 this this DT 1071 1080 territory territory NN 1081 1083 is be VBZ 1084 1092 occupied occupy VBN 1092 1093 ” '' '' 1094 1095 - - HYPH 1096 1100 must must MD 1101 1103 be be VB 1104 1112 accorded accord VBN 1113 1121 prisoner prisoner NN 1122 1124 of of IN 1125 1128 war war NN 1129 1135 status status NN 1135 1136 . . . 1137 1140 The the DT 1141 1151 convention convention NN 1152 1159 exempts exempt VBZ 1160 1164 only only RB 1165 1170 those those DT 1170 1171 , , , 1172 1176 such such JJ 1177 1179 as as IN 1180 1185 spies spy NNS 1186 1189 and and CC 1190 1199 saboteurs saboteur NNS 1199 1200 , , , 1201 1204 who who WP 1205 1207 do do VBP 1208 1211 not not RB 1212 1219 clearly clearly RB 1220 1228 identify identify VB 1229 1239 themselves themselves PRP 1240 1242 as as IN 1243 1255 belligerents belligerent NNS 1255 1256 . . . 1257 1260 But but CC 1261 1268 clearly clearly RB 1269 1271 it it PRP 1272 1275 was be VBD 1276 1281 meant mean VBN 1282 1284 to to TO 1285 1290 apply apply VB 1291 1293 to to TO 1294 1297 the the DT 1298 1305 Taliban Taliban NNP 1306 1309 and and CC 1310 1312 Al Al NNP 1313 1319 Qa’ida Qa'ida NNP 1320 1328 fighters fighter NNS 1329 1337 captured capture VBD 1338 1343 after after IN 1344 1351 vicious vicious JJ 1352 1359 battles battle NNS 1360 1362 in in IN 1363 1374 Afghanistan Afghanistan NNP 1374 1375 , , , 1376 1384 fighters fighter NNS 1385 1388 who who WP 1389 1393 made make VBD 1394 1396 no no DT 1397 1403 secret secret NN 1404 1406 of of IN 1407 1410 who who WP 1411 1415 they they PRP 1416 1420 were be VBD 1420 1421 , , , 1422 1426 what what WP 1427 1431 they they PRP 1432 1436 were be VBD 1437 1447 supporting support VBG 1448 1451 and and CC 1452 1455 who who WP 1456 1460 they they PRP 1461 1468 thought think VBD 1469 1474 their their PRP$ 1475 1482 enemies enemy NNS 1483 1487 were be VBD 1487 1488 . . . 1495 1498 But but CC 1499 1503 then then RB 1503 1504 , , , 1505 1507 if if IN 1508 1512 they they PRP 1513 1517 were be VBD 1518 1523 dealt deal VBN 1524 1528 with with IN 1529 1537 properly properly RB 1537 1538 , , , 1539 1542 the the DT 1543 1547 U.S. U.S. NNP 1548 1553 would would MD 1554 1558 have have VB 1559 1563 less less JJR 1564 1570 leeway leeway NN 1570 1571 . . . 1572 1577 Under under IN 1578 1581 the the DT 1582 1588 Geneva Geneva NNP 1589 1599 Convention Convention NNP 1599 1600 , , , 1601 1610 prisoners prisoner NNS 1611 1613 of of IN 1614 1617 war war NN 1618 1622 must must MD 1623 1625 be be VB 1626 1633 treated treat VBN 1634 1642 humanely humanely RB 1642 1643 . . . 1644 1649 Their their PRP$ 1650 1657 captors captor NNS 1658 1661 are be VBP 1662 1671 forbidden forbidden JJ 1672 1676 from from IN 1677 1687 inflicting inflict VBG 1688 1689 “ `` `` 1689 1697 outrages outrage NNS 1698 1702 upon upon IN 1703 1711 personal personal JJ 1712 1719 dignity dignity NN 1719 1720 ” '' '' 1721 1723 or or CC 1724 1725 “ `` `` 1725 1733 inhumane inhumane NN 1734 1737 and and CC 1738 1747 degrading degrade VBG 1748 1757 treatment treatment NN 1757 1758 . . . 1758 1759 ” '' '' 1760 1769 Prisoners prisoner NNS 1770 1772 of of IN 1773 1776 war war NN 1777 1780 are be VBP 1781 1784 not not RB 1785 1793 required require VBN 1794 1796 to to TO 1797 1801 give give VB 1802 1807 their their PRP$ 1808 1815 captors captor NNS 1816 1827 information information NN 1828 1834 beyond beyond IN 1835 1839 name name NN 1839 1840 , , , 1841 1845 rank rank NN 1846 1849 and and CC 1850 1856 serial serial JJ 1857 1863 number number NN 1863 1864 . . . 1865 1870 Under under IN 1871 1874 the the DT 1875 1885 convention convention NN 1885 1886 , , , 1887 1891 they they PRP 1892 1896 must must MD 1897 1898 “ `` `` 1898 1900 be be VB 1901 1910 quartered quarter VBN 1911 1916 under under IN 1917 1927 conditions condition NNS 1928 1930 as as RB 1931 1941 favourable favourable JJ 1942 1944 as as IN 1945 1950 those those DT 1951 1954 for for IN 1955 1961 forces force NNS 1962 1964 of of IN 1965 1968 the the DT 1969 1978 detaining detain VBG 1979 1984 power power NN 1985 1988 who who WP 1989 1992 are be VBP 1993 2001 billeted billet VBN 2002 2004 in in IN 2005 2008 the the DT 2009 2013 same same JJ 2014 2018 area area NN 2018 2019 . . . 2019 2020 ” '' '' 2027 2029 To to TO 2030 2032 be be VB 2033 2037 more more RBR 2038 2045 precise precise JJ 2045 2046 , , , 2047 2056 prisoners prisoner NNS 2057 2059 of of IN 2060 2063 war war NN 2064 2067 are be VBP 2068 2071 not not RB 2072 2074 to to TO 2075 2077 be be VB 2078 2085 treated treat VBN 2086 2090 like like IN 2091 2096 those those DT 2097 2103 jailed jail VBN 2104 2106 by by IN 2107 2110 the the DT 2111 2115 U.S. U.S. NNP 2116 2118 at at IN 2119 2122 its its PRP$ 2123 2133 Guantanamo Guantanamo NNP 2134 2137 Bay Bay NNP 2138 2143 naval naval JJ 2144 2148 base base NN 2149 2151 in in IN 2152 2156 Cuba Cuba NNP 2156 2157 . . . 2158 2163 Those those DT 2164 2173 detainees detainee NNS 2173 2174 , , , 2175 2182 brought bring VBD 2183 2191 shackled shackle VBN 2191 2192 , , , 2193 2199 shaved shave VBN 2200 2203 and and CC 2204 2215 blindfolded blindfold VBN 2216 2218 to to TO 2219 2223 Cuba Cuba NNP 2223 2224 , , , 2225 2228 are be VBP 2229 2233 kept keep VBN 2234 2236 in in IN 2237 2242 chain chain NN 2243 2247 link link NN 2248 2252 pens pen VBZ 2253 2258 under under IN 2259 2262 the the DT 2263 2271 constant constant JJ 2272 2277 glare glare NN 2277 2278 , , , 2279 2284 night night NN 2285 2288 and and CC 2289 2292 day day NN 2292 2293 , , , 2294 2296 of of IN 2297 2304 halogen halogen NN 2305 2310 lamps lamp NNS 2310 2311 . . . 2312 2313 ( ( ( 2313 2316 The the DT 2317 2329 blindfolding blindfolding NN 2329 2330 , , , 2331 2341 deliberate deliberate JJ 2342 2356 disorientation disorientation NN 2356 2357 , , , 2358 2368 discomfort discomfort NN 2369 2372 and and CC 2373 2381 constant constant JJ 2382 2387 light light NN 2388 2391 are be VBP 2392 2399 staples staple NNS 2400 2402 of of IN 2403 2409 police police NN 2410 2416 states state NNS 2417 2420 all all DT 2421 2425 over over IN 2426 2429 the the DT 2430 2435 world world NN 2435 2436 . . . 2437 2440 The the DT 2441 2445 idea idea NN 2446 2448 is be VBZ 2449 2451 to to TO 2452 2457 break break VB 2458 2462 down down RP 2463 2466 the the DT 2467 2473 inmate inmate NN 2473 2474 , , , 2475 2481 weaken weaken VB 2482 2485 him him PRP 2486 2490 from from IN 2491 2495 lack lack NN 2496 2498 of of IN 2499 2504 sleep sleep NN 2505 2508 and and CC 2509 2516 thereby thereby RB 2517 2521 make make VB 2522 2525 him him PRP 2526 2530 more more RBR 2531 2538 pliable pliable JJ 2539 2543 when when WRB 2544 2547 the the DT 2548 2561 interrogators interrogator NNS 2562 2567 begin begin VBP 2568 2573 their their PRP$ 2574 2581 serious serious JJ 2582 2586 work work NN 2586 2587 ) ) ) 2587 2588 . . . 2589 2599 Washington Washington NNP 2600 2602 is be VBZ 2603 2609 brazen brazen JJ 2610 2615 about about IN 2616 2619 its its PRP$ 2620 2628 flouting flouting NN 2629 2631 of of IN 2632 2645 international international JJ 2646 2649 law law NN 2649 2650 , , , 2651 2657 secure secure JJ 2658 2660 in in IN 2661 2664 the the DT 2665 2674 knowledge knowledge NN 2675 2679 that that IN 2680 2687 neither neither CC 2688 2691 its its PRP$ 2692 2700 citizens citizen NNS 2701 2704 not not RB 2705 2708 its its PRP$ 2709 2715 allies ally NNS 2716 2720 will will MD 2721 2729 complain complain VB 2729 2730 . . . 2731 2737 Indeed indeed RB 2737 2738 , , , 2739 2743 many many JJ 2744 2753 Americans American NNPS 2754 2755 ( ( ( 2755 2758 and and CC 2759 2763 some some DT 2764 2773 Canadians Canadian NNPS 2773 2774 ) ) ) 2775 2783 probably probably RB 2784 2789 think think VBP 2790 2796 anyone anyone NN 2797 2806 connected connect VBN 2807 2809 to to TO 2810 2813 the the DT 2814 2819 Sept. Sept. NNP 2820 2822 11 11 CD 2823 2829 terror terror NN 2830 2837 attacks attack NNS 2838 2846 deserves deserve NNS 2847 2855 whatever whatever WDT 2856 2858 he he PRP 2859 2863 gets get VBZ 2863 2864 . . . 2871 2876 There there EX 2877 2880 are be VBP 2880 2881 , , , 2882 2889 however however RB 2889 2890 , , , 2891 2892 a a DT 2893 2899 couple couple NN 2900 2902 of of IN 2903 2911 problems problem NNS 2912 2916 with with IN 2917 2921 this this DT 2922 2936 understandable understandable JJ 2936 2937 , , , 2938 2940 if if IN 2941 2950 knee-jerk knee-jerk NN 2950 2951 , , , 2952 2960 response response NN 2960 2961 . . . 2962 2967 First first RB 2967 2968 , , , 2969 2971 it it PRP 2972 2979 assumes assume VBZ 2980 2984 that that IN 2985 2990 those those DT 2991 2999 selected select VBN 3000 3003 for for IN 3004 3014 Guantanamo Guantanamo NNP 3015 3018 are be VBP 3019 3028 connected connect VBN 3029 3031 to to TO 3032 3035 the the DT 3036 3041 Sept. Sept. NNP 3042 3044 11 11 CD 3045 3052 attacks attack NNS 3052 3053 . . . 3054 3059 Maybe maybe RB 3060 3064 some some DT 3065 3068 are be VBP 3069 3070 ( ( ( 3070 3078 although although IN 3079 3082 the the DT 3083 3088 world world NN 3089 3094 would would MD 3095 3099 have have VB 3100 3101 a a DT 3102 3108 better good JJR 3109 3113 idea idea NN 3114 3116 if if IN 3117 3120 the the DT 3121 3125 U.S. U.S. NNP 3125 3126 , , , 3127 3129 in in IN 3130 3134 line line NN 3135 3139 with with IN 3140 3143 the the DT 3144 3150 Geneva Geneva NNP 3151 3161 Convention Convention NNP 3161 3162 , , , 3163 3172 specified specify VBD 3173 3177 just just RB 3178 3181 who who WP 3182 3184 it it PRP 3185 3188 was be VBD 3189 3196 holding hold VBG 3196 3197 ) ) ) 3197 3198 . . . 3199 3203 More more RBR 3204 3210 likely likely JJ 3211 3217 though though IN 3217 3218 , , , 3219 3222 the the DT 3223 3227 U.S. U.S. NNP 3228 3230 is be VBZ 3231 3236 using use VBG 3237 3240 the the DT 3241 3249 broadest broad JJS 3250 3252 of of IN 3253 3259 brooms broom NNS 3260 3262 to to TO 3263 3268 sweep sweep VB 3269 3271 up up RP 3272 3281 detainees detainee NNS 3282 3285 for for IN 3286 3290 Cuba Cuba NNP 3290 3291 . . . 3292 3300 American american JJ 3301 3313 intelligence intelligence NN 3314 3322 agencies agency NNS 3323 3324 - - : 3325 3331 doubly doubly RB 3332 3343 embarrassed embarrass VBN 3344 3346 by by IN 3347 3352 their their PRP$ 3353 3360 failure failure NN 3361 3363 to to TO 3364 3371 foresee foresee VB 3372 3375 the the DT 3376 3381 Sept. Sept. NNP 3382 3384 11 11 CD 3385 3391 attack attack NN 3392 3395 and and CC 3396 3401 their their PRP$ 3402 3411 inability inability NN 3412 3414 to to TO 3415 3421 locate locate VB 3422 3427 Usama Usama NNP 3428 3431 Bin Bin NNP 3432 3437 Ladin Ladin NNP 3438 3439 - - : 3440 3443 are be VBP 3444 3452 probably probably RB 3453 3456 not not RB 3457 3462 picky picky VB 3463 3468 about about IN 3469 3472 who who WP 3473 3477 they they PRP 3478 3485 subject subject VBP 3486 3488 to to TO 3489 3490 “ `` `` 3490 3497 intense intense JJ 3498 3511 interrogation interrogation NN 3511 3512 . . . 3512 3513 ” '' '' 3520 3523 The the DT 3524 3528 more more RBR 3529 3540 fundamental fundamental JJ 3541 3548 problem problem NN 3548 3549 , , , 3550 3556 though though RB 3556 3557 , , , 3558 3561 has have VBZ 3562 3564 to to TO 3565 3567 do do VB 3568 3572 with with IN 3573 3578 logic logic NN 3578 3579 . . . 3580 3582 Is be VBZ 3583 3586 the the DT 3587 3590 war war NN 3591 3593 on on IN 3594 3603 terrorism terrorism NN 3604 3605 a a DT 3606 3609 war war NN 3610 3612 or or CC 3613 3615 is be VBZ 3616 3618 it it PRP 3619 3622 not not RB 3622 3623 ? ? . 3624 3628 Many many JJ 3629 3630 ( ( ( 3630 3639 including include VBG 3640 3642 me me PRP 3642 3643 ) ) ) 3644 3647 saw see VBD 3648 3651 the the DT 3652 3659 attacks attack NNS 3660 3662 on on IN 3663 3666 New New NNP 3667 3671 York York NNP 3672 3674 as as IN 3675 3676 a a DT 3677 3686 monstrous monstrous JJ 3687 3695 criminal criminal JJ 3696 3703 outrage outrage NN 3703 3704 , , , 3705 3711 rather rather RB 3712 3716 than than IN 3717 3719 an an DT 3720 3723 act act NN 3724 3726 of of IN 3727 3730 war war NN 3730 3731 . . . 3732 3735 But but CC 3736 3745 President President NNP 3746 3752 George George NNP 3753 3755 W. W. NNP 3756 3760 Bush Bush NNP 3761 3771 determined determine VBD 3772 3781 otherwise otherwise RB 3781 3782 . . . 3783 3785 By by IN 3786 3794 treating treat VBG 3795 3800 Sept. Sept. NNP 3801 3803 11 11 CD 3804 3806 as as IN 3807 3810 war war NN 3810 3811 , , , 3812 3816 Bush Bush NNP 3817 3820 was be VBD 3821 3825 able able JJ 3826 3828 to to TO 3829 3833 call call VB 3834 3838 into into IN 3839 3843 play play VB 3844 3847 the the DT 3848 3853 right right NN 3854 3856 of of IN 3857 3869 self-defence self-defence NN 3870 3878 mandated mandate VBN 3879 3881 by by IN 3882 3885 the the DT 3886 3892 United United NNP 3893 3900 Nations Nation NNPS 3900 3901 . . . 3902 3905 But but CC 3906 3908 if if IN 3909 3914 Sept. Sept. NNP 3915 3917 11 11 CD 3918 3921 was be VBD 3922 3924 an an DT 3925 3928 act act NN 3929 3931 of of IN 3932 3935 war war NN 3935 3936 , , , 3937 3941 then then RB 3942 3944 it it PRP 3945 3952 becomes become VBZ 3952 3953 , , , 3954 3956 in in IN 3957 3958 a a DT 3959 3964 weird weird JJ 3965 3968 way way NN 3968 3969 , , , 3970 3974 less less RBR 3975 3984 monstrous monstrous JJ 3984 3985 . . . 3986 3990 Both both DT 3991 3994 New New NNP 3995 3999 York York NNP 4000 4004 City City NNP 4005 4008 and and CC 4009 4012 the the DT 4013 4021 Pentagon Pentagon NNP 4022 4025 are be VBP 4026 4036 legitimate legitimate JJ 4037 4044 wartime wartime NN 4045 4052 targets target NNS 4053 4054 - - : 4055 4058 the the DT 4059 4065 former former JJ 4066 4074 economic economic JJ 4074 4075 , , , 4076 4079 the the DT 4080 4086 latter latter JJ 4087 4095 military military NN 4095 4096 . . . 4097 4103 Anyone anyone NN 4104 4110 waging waging NN 4111 4114 war war NN 4115 4117 on on IN 4118 4121 the the DT 4122 4126 U.S. U.S. NNP 4127 4132 would would MD 4133 4137 have have VB 4138 4146 targeted target VBN 4147 4156 Manhattan Manhattan NNP 4157 4159 in in IN 4160 4163 the the DT 4164 4168 hope hope NN 4169 4171 of of IN 4172 4180 damaging damage VBG 4181 4184 the the DT 4185 4193 American american JJ 4194 4201 economy economy NN 4202 4203 - - HYPH 4204 4206 as as IN 4207 4210 the the DT 4211 4216 World World NNP 4217 4222 Trade Trade NNP 4223 4229 Center Center NNP 4230 4236 attack attack NN 4237 4240 did do VBD 4240 4241 . . . 4248 4250 So so RB 4251 4253 if if IN 4254 4259 Sept. Sept. NNP 4260 4262 11 11 CD 4263 4266 was be VBD 4267 4269 an an DT 4270 4273 act act NN 4274 4276 of of IN 4277 4280 war war NN 4280 4281 , , , 4282 4285 why why WRB 4286 4289 are be VBP 4290 4295 those those DT 4296 4304 captured capture VBN 4305 4307 in in IN 4308 4311 the the DT 4312 4321 aftermath aftermath NN 4322 4325 not not RB 4326 4333 treated treat VBN 4334 4336 as as IN 4337 4346 prisoners prisoner NNS 4347 4349 of of IN 4350 4353 war war NN 4353 4354 ? ? . 4355 4357 It it PRP 4358 4360 is be VBZ 4361 4371 considered consider VBN 4372 4382 legitimate legitimate JJ 4383 4395 self-defence self-defence NN 4396 4399 for for IN 4400 4403 the the DT 4404 4408 U.S. U.S. NNP 4409 4412 and and CC 4413 4416 its its PRP$ 4417 4423 allies ally NNS 4424 4426 to to TO 4427 4433 invade invade VB 4434 4445 Afghanistan Afghanistan NNP 4445 4446 . . . 4447 4450 Why why WRB 4451 4453 is be VBZ 4454 4456 it it PRP 4457 4460 not not RB 4461 4471 considered consider VBD 4472 4479 equally equally RB 4480 4490 legitimate legitimate JJ 4491 4494 for for IN 4495 4498 the the DT 4499 4506 Afghans Afghan NNPS 4507 4510 and and CC 4511 4516 their their PRP$ 4517 4523 allies ally NNS 4524 4526 to to TO 4527 4533 resist resist VB 4534 4538 this this DT 4539 4547 invasion invasion NN 4547 4548 ? ? . 4555 4560 These these DT 4561 4564 are be VBP 4565 4568 not not RB 4569 4577 abstract abstract VB 4578 4587 questions question NNS 4587 4588 . . . 4589 4598 Countries Country NNP 4599 4603 sign sign NN 4604 4606 on on IN 4607 4609 to to TO 4610 4613 the the DT 4614 4620 Geneva Geneva NNP 4621 4631 Convention Convention NNP 4632 4635 not not RB 4636 4638 to to TO 4639 4641 be be VB 4642 4652 altruistic altruistic JJ 4653 4656 but but CC 4657 4659 to to TO 4660 4666 ensure ensure VB 4667 4671 that that IN 4672 4677 their their PRP$ 4678 4681 own own JJ 4682 4690 soldiers soldier NNS 4691 4695 will will MD 4696 4698 be be VB 4699 4703 well well RB 4704 4711 treated treat VBN 4712 4714 if if IN 4715 4723 captured capture VBN 4723 4724 . . . 4725 4728 The the DT 4729 4739 assumption assumption NN 4740 4742 is be VBZ 4743 4747 that that IN 4748 4752 what what WP 4753 4755 we we PRP 4756 4758 do do VBP 4759 4761 to to TO 4762 4766 them them PRP 4767 4771 will will MD 4772 4774 be be VB 4775 4779 done do VBN 4780 4782 to to TO 4783 4785 us us PRP 4785 4786 . . . 4787 4790 Let let VB 4791 4793 us us PRP 4794 4798 hope hope VB 4799 4803 that that IN 4803 4804 , , , 4805 4807 in in IN 4808 4812 this this DT 4813 4821 instance instance NN 4821 4822 , , , 4823 4826 the the DT 4827 4835 terrible terrible JJ 4836 4844 equation equation NN 4845 4849 does do VBZ 4850 4853 not not RB 4854 4858 hold hold VB 4858 4859 . . .