2 7 These these DT 8 12 days day NNS 12 13 , , , 14 18 when when WRB 19 29 everything everything NN 30 35 seems seem VBZ 36 38 to to TO 39 41 be be VB 42 52 collapsing collapse VBG 53 55 in in IN 56 59 the the DT 60 66 Middle Middle NNP 67 71 East East NNP 71 72 , , , 73 77 both both DT 78 81 the the DT 82 94 Palestinians Palestinian NNPS 94 95 ’ ' POS 96 103 chances chance NNS 104 106 of of IN 107 114 finally finally RB 115 121 having have VBG 122 123 a a DT 124 129 state state NN 130 132 in in IN 133 138 which which WDT 139 144 their their PRP$ 145 151 people people NNS 152 157 would would MD 158 160 be be VB 161 170 sovereign sovereign JJ 170 171 , , , 172 175 and and CC 176 179 the the DT 180 188 Israelis Israeli NNPS 188 189 ’ ' POS 190 197 chances chance NNS 198 200 of of IN 201 212 integrating integrate VBG 213 223 themselves themselves PRP 224 228 into into IN 229 230 a a DT 231 237 region region NN 238 243 where where WRB 244 246 – -- : 247 251 need need VBP 252 254 we we PRP 255 257 be be VB 258 266 reminded remind VBN 266 267 ? ? . 268 270 – -- : 271 274 the the DT 275 280 Arabs Arab NNPS 281 284 are be VBP 285 287 in in IN 288 291 the the DT 292 304 overwhelming overwhelming JJ 305 313 majority majority NN 313 314 , , , 315 317 we we PRP 318 325 believe believe VBP 326 328 it it PRP 329 332 our our PRP$ 333 337 duty duty NN 338 340 to to TO 341 346 voice voice VB 347 348 a a DT 349 352 few few JJ 353 358 basic basic JJ 359 365 truths truth NNS 365 366 . . . 373 376 One one CD 377 379 of of IN 380 382 us us PRP 383 385 is be VBZ 386 387 a a DT 388 399 Palestinian palestinian JJ 400 407 patriot patriot NN 408 409 ( ( ( 409 412 and and CC 413 416 not not RB 417 418 a a DT 419 430 nationalist nationalist NN 430 431 ) ) ) 431 432 . . . 433 436 The the DT 437 442 other other JJ 443 446 has have VBZ 447 449 no no DT 450 455 other other JJ 456 464 homeland homeland NN 465 469 than than IN 470 476 France France NNP 476 477 , , , 478 483 which which WDT 484 488 does do VBZ 489 492 not not RB 492 493 , , , 494 501 however however RB 501 502 , , , 503 507 lead lead VBD 508 511 him him PRP 512 514 to to TO 515 519 deny deny VB 520 523 his his PRP$ 524 532 heritage heritage NN 533 537 from from IN 538 545 ancient ancient JJ 546 552 Israel Israel NNP 553 554 ( ( ( 554 559 which which WDT 560 568 contains contain VBZ 568 569 , , , 570 574 like like IN 575 578 all all DT 579 588 heritages heritage NNS 588 589 , , , 590 593 the the DT 594 598 best good JJS 599 602 and and CC 603 606 the the DT 607 612 worst worst JJS 612 613 ) ) ) 614 617 nor nor CC 618 620 to to TO 621 623 be be VB 624 635 indifferent indifferent JJ 636 638 to to TO 639 642 the the DT 643 650 destiny destiny NN 651 653 of of IN 654 659 those those DT 660 668 millions million NNS 669 671 of of IN 672 676 Jews Jew NNPS 677 680 who who WP 681 685 have have VBP 686 695 something something NN 696 698 in in IN 699 705 common common JJ 706 710 with with IN 711 714 him him PRP 714 715 . . . 722 724 We we PRP 725 728 are be VBP 729 733 both both DT 734 744 historians historian NNS 744 745 . . . 752 759 However however RB 759 760 , , , 761 763 we we PRP 764 768 will will MD 769 772 not not RB 773 777 look look VB 778 782 back back RB 783 785 at at IN 786 789 the the DT 790 796 entire entire JJ 797 804 century century NN 805 809 that that WDT 810 813 has have VBZ 814 818 just just RB 819 825 passed pass VBN 825 826 . . . 827 832 There there EX 833 836 was be VBD 837 838 a a DT 839 846 quarrel quarrel NN 847 857 concerning concern VBG 858 865 Zionism zionism NN 865 866 . . . 867 872 Those those DT 873 881 involved involve VBN 882 884 in in IN 885 887 it it PRP 888 891 had have VBD 892 894 no no DT 895 903 shortage shortage NN 904 906 of of IN 907 916 arguments argument NNS 916 917 , , , 918 925 whether whether IN 926 930 Arab Arab NNP 930 931 , , , 932 938 Jewish Jewish NNP 938 939 , , , 940 942 or or CC 943 949 simply simply RB 950 962 clear-headed clear-headed JJ 962 963 . . . 964 971 Zionism Zionism NNP 972 983 established establish VBD 984 990 itself itself PRP 991 993 in in IN 994 995 a a DT 996 1005 sensitive sensitive JJ 1006 1012 region region NN 1013 1015 of of IN 1016 1019 the the DT 1020 1025 world world NN 1026 1028 at at IN 1029 1030 a a DT 1031 1035 time time NN 1036 1040 when when WRB 1041 1048 nothing nothing NN 1049 1055 seemed seem VBD 1056 1060 more more RBR 1061 1062 “ `` `` 1062 1068 normal normal JJ 1068 1069 ” '' '' 1070 1074 than than IN 1075 1077 to to TO 1078 1084 settle settle VB 1085 1087 in in IN 1088 1095 someone someone NN 1096 1100 else else RB 1100 1102 ’s 's POS 1103 1112 territory territory NN 1112 1113 . . . 1120 1123 The the DT 1124 1130 United United NNP 1131 1137 States State NNPS 1137 1138 , , , 1139 1145 Canada Canada NNP 1145 1146 , , , 1147 1156 Australia Australia NNP 1156 1157 , , , 1158 1161 and and CC 1162 1165 New New NNP 1166 1173 Zealand Zealand NNP 1174 1178 were be VBD 1179 1182 all all DT 1183 1190 created create VBN 1191 1193 at at IN 1194 1197 the the DT 1198 1208 conclusion conclusion NN 1209 1211 of of IN 1212 1213 a a DT 1214 1222 colonial colonial JJ 1223 1230 process process NN 1230 1231 . . . 1238 1240 No no DT 1241 1244 one one CD 1245 1250 today today NN 1251 1261 challenges challenge VBZ 1262 1267 their their PRP$ 1268 1277 existence existence NN 1278 1285 despite despite IN 1286 1289 the the DT 1290 1296 crises crisis NNS 1297 1304 arising arise VBG 1305 1309 from from IN 1310 1314 this this DT 1315 1322 process process NN 1323 1326 and and CC 1327 1332 which which WDT 1333 1337 were be VBD 1338 1343 cited cite VBN 1344 1346 by by IN 1347 1349 an an DT 1350 1360 Aboriginal aboriginal JJ 1361 1368 athlete athlete NN 1369 1371 at at IN 1372 1375 the the DT 1376 1383 Olympic Olympic NNP 1384 1389 Games Game NNPS 1390 1392 in in IN 1393 1399 Sydney Sydney NNP 1399 1400 . . . 1407 1415 Likewise likewise RB 1415 1416 , , , 1417 1420 the the DT 1421 1425 more more RBR 1426 1432 recent recent JJ 1433 1441 creation creation NN 1442 1444 of of IN 1445 1451 Israel Israel NNP 1452 1455 was be VBD 1456 1467 accompanied accompany VBN 1467 1468 , , , 1469 1474 under under IN 1475 1478 the the DT 1479 1490 indifferent indifferent JJ 1491 1495 gaze gaze NN 1496 1498 of of IN 1499 1502 the the DT 1503 1510 Western western JJ 1511 1514 and and CC 1515 1521 Soviet soviet JJ 1522 1527 world world NN 1527 1528 , , , 1529 1531 by by IN 1532 1535 the the DT 1536 1542 forced force VBN 1543 1549 exodus exodus NN 1550 1552 of of IN 1553 1561 hundreds hundred NNS 1562 1564 of of IN 1565 1574 thousands thousand NNS 1575 1577 of of IN 1578 1590 Palestinians Palestinian NNPS 1590 1591 . . . 1592 1597 Today Today NNP 1597 1598 , , , 1599 1604 these these DT 1605 1613 refugees refugee NNS 1614 1617 and and CC 1618 1623 their their PRP$ 1624 1635 descendants descendant NNS 1636 1638 do do VBP 1639 1642 not not RB 1643 1647 call call VB 1648 1652 into into IN 1653 1661 question question NN 1662 1665 the the DT 1666 1675 existence existence NN 1676 1678 of of IN 1679 1682 the the DT 1683 1688 state state NN 1689 1691 of of IN 1692 1698 Israel Israel NNP 1699 1701 as as RB 1702 1706 long long RB 1707 1709 as as IN 1710 1713 the the DT 1714 1723 injustice injustice NN 1724 1732 suffered suffer VBN 1733 1735 is be VBZ 1736 1746 recognized recognize VBN 1747 1750 and and CC 1751 1754 the the DT 1755 1769 implementation implementation NN 1770 1772 of of IN 1773 1778 their their PRP$ 1779 1785 rights right NNS 1786 1788 is be VBZ 1789 1799 negotiated negotiate VBN 1800 1806 fairly fairly RB 1806 1807 . . . 1814 1817 Let let VB 1818 1820 us us PRP 1821 1828 content content VB 1829 1838 ourselves ourselves PRP 1839 1843 with with IN 1844 1855 reiterating reiterate VBG 1856 1859 the the DT 1860 1868 evidence evidence NN 1868 1869 : : : 1870 1875 Since since IN 1876 1880 June June NNP 1881 1885 1967 1967 CD 1885 1886 , , , 1887 1890 the the DT 1891 1895 West West NNP 1896 1900 Bank Bank NNP 1901 1904 and and CC 1905 1909 Gaza Gaza NNP 1910 1914 have have VBP 1915 1919 been be VBN 1920 1928 occupied occupy VBN 1929 1932 and and CC 1933 1942 dominated dominate VBN 1943 1954 territories territory NNS 1954 1955 , , , 1956 1963 crushed crush VBD 1964 1975 politically politically RB 1975 1976 , , , 1977 1985 socially socially RB 1985 1986 , , , 1987 1999 economically economically RB 1999 2000 . . . 2001 2008 Despite despite IN 2009 2013 this this DT 2013 2014 , , , 2015 2018 the the DT 2019 2030 Palestinian palestinian JJ 2031 2041 resistance resistance NN 2042 2045 has have VBZ 2046 2054 formally formally RB 2055 2065 recognized recognize VBN 2066 2069 the the DT 2070 2079 existence existence NN 2080 2082 of of IN 2083 2089 Israel Israel NNP 2090 2093 and and CC 2094 2099 begun begin VBN 2100 2101 a a DT 2102 2107 peace peace NN 2108 2115 process process NN 2116 2118 in in IN 2119 2123 Oslo Oslo NNP 2123 2124 , , , 2125 2130 while while IN 2131 2134 the the DT 2135 2140 state state NN 2141 2143 of of IN 2144 2150 Israel Israel NNP 2151 2154 has have VBZ 2155 2165 recognized recognize VBN 2166 2169 the the DT 2170 2182 Palestinians Palestinian NNPS 2183 2194 represented represent VBN 2195 2197 by by IN 2198 2201 the the DT 2202 2205 PLO PLO NNP 2206 2209 and and CC 2210 2213 its its PRP$ 2214 2220 leader leader NN 2221 2227 Yasser Yasser NNP 2228 2234 Arafat Arafat NNP 2234 2235 . . . 2242 2246 This this DT 2247 2254 process process NN 2255 2258 has have VBZ 2259 2262 not not RB 2263 2271 achieved achieve VBN 2272 2275 its its PRP$ 2276 2280 goal goal NN 2280 2281 . . . 2288 2290 On on IN 2291 2294 the the DT 2295 2306 Palestinian palestinian JJ 2307 2311 side side NN 2311 2312 , , , 2313 2320 feeding feed VBG 2321 2323 on on IN 2324 2327 the the DT 2328 2335 growing grow VBG 2336 2347 frustration frustration NN 2348 2350 of of IN 2351 2354 the the DT 2355 2363 occupied occupied JJ 2364 2374 population population NN 2374 2375 , , , 2376 2377 a a DT 2378 2382 wing wing NN 2383 2386 has have VBZ 2387 2393 broken break VBN 2394 2397 off off RP 2397 2398 , , , 2399 2409 conducting conduct VBG 2410 2411 a a DT 2412 2418 policy policy NN 2419 2421 of of IN 2422 2428 terror terror NN 2429 2432 and and CC 2433 2438 death death NN 2439 2443 that that WDT 2444 2453 horrifies horrify VBZ 2454 2456 us us PRP 2456 2457 . . . 2464 2466 On on IN 2467 2470 the the DT 2471 2478 Israeli israeli JJ 2479 2483 side side NN 2483 2484 , , , 2485 2492 despite despite IN 2493 2496 the the DT 2497 2504 process process NN 2504 2505 , , , 2506 2516 settlement settlement NN 2517 2520 has have VBZ 2521 2530 increased increase VBN 2531 2543 considerably considerably RB 2543 2544 , , , 2545 2551 eating eat VBG 2552 2556 away away RP 2557 2559 at at IN 2560 2563 the the DT 2564 2574 supposedly supposedly RB 2575 2585 autonomous autonomous JJ 2586 2597 Palestinian palestinian JJ 2598 2609 territories territory NNS 2610 2622 crisscrossed crisscross VBN 2623 2625 by by IN 2626 2627 “ `` `` 2627 2633 bypass bypass JJ 2634 2639 roads road NNS 2639 2640 . . . 2640 2641 ” '' '' 2648 2653 Today Today NNP 2653 2654 , , , 2655 2658 two two CD 2659 2664 forms form NNS 2665 2667 of of IN 2668 2677 terrorism terrorism NN 2678 2682 fuel fuel NN 2683 2687 each each DT 2688 2693 other other JJ 2693 2694 . . . 2695 2706 Palestinian palestinian JJ 2707 2716 terrorism terrorism NN 2716 2717 , , , 2718 2723 which which WDT 2724 2731 existed exist VBD 2732 2734 on on IN 2735 2736 a a DT 2737 2741 very very RB 2742 2747 small small JJ 2748 2753 scale scale NN 2754 2756 in in IN 2757 2760 the the DT 2761 2765 time time NN 2766 2768 of of IN 2769 2776 Yitzhak Yitzhak NNP 2777 2782 Rabin Rabin NNP 2782 2783 , , , 2784 2787 has have VBZ 2788 2793 taken take VBN 2794 2796 on on IN 2797 2798 a a DT 2799 2807 dramatic dramatic JJ 2808 2817 dimension dimension NN 2817 2818 . . . 2819 2822 But but CC 2823 2826 the the DT 2827 2834 Israeli israeli JJ 2835 2843 response response NN 2843 2844 , , , 2845 2849 with with IN 2850 2853 its its PRP$ 2854 2855 “ `` `` 2855 2869 extra-judicial extra-judicial JJ 2870 2882 liquidations liquidation NNS 2882 2883 , , , 2883 2884 ” '' '' 2885 2887 is be VBZ 2888 2892 even even RB 2893 2897 more more RBR 2898 2906 dramatic dramatic JJ 2907 2909 in in IN 2910 2911 a a DT 2912 2919 certain certain JJ 2920 2925 sense sense NN 2925 2926 . . . 2927 2929 It it PRP 2930 2933 now now RB 2934 2943 resembles resemble VBZ 2944 2947 the the DT 2948 2959 destruction destruction NN 2960 2962 of of IN 2963 2966 the the DT 2967 2971 very very JJ 2972 2978 people people NNS 2978 2979 , , , 2980 2982 so so RB 2983 2993 structured structured JJ 2994 2997 and and CC 2998 3007 organized organize VBN 3008 3010 is be VBZ 3011 3013 it it PRP 3013 3014 . . . 3021 3025 Like like IN 3026 3029 any any DT 3030 3034 form form NN 3035 3037 of of IN 3038 3043 state state NN 3044 3053 terrorism terrorism NN 3053 3054 , , , 3055 3057 it it PRP 3058 3060 is be VBZ 3061 3066 above above IN 3067 3070 all all DT 3071 3084 contradictory contradictory NN 3084 3085 . . . 3086 3095 Yesterday yesterday NN 3095 3096 , , , 3097 3103 Yasser Yasser NNP 3104 3110 Arafat Arafat NNP 3111 3114 was be VBD 3115 3120 being be VBG 3121 3126 asked ask VBD 3127 3129 to to TO 3130 3136 police police VB 3137 3140 the the DT 3141 3145 area area NN 3146 3148 he he PRP 3149 3152 was be VBD 3153 3161 supposed suppose VBN 3162 3164 to to TO 3165 3167 be be VB 3168 3170 in in IN 3171 3177 charge charge NN 3178 3180 of of IN 3180 3181 , , , 3182 3187 while while IN 3188 3198 destroying destroy VBG 3199 3202 the the DT 3203 3214 instruments instrument NNS 3215 3217 of of IN 3218 3221 his his PRP$ 3222 3227 power power NN 3227 3228 . . . 3229 3234 Today today NN 3234 3235 , , , 3236 3238 he he PRP 3239 3241 is be VBZ 3242 3247 being be VBG 3248 3258 completely completely RB 3259 3267 isolated isolate VBN 3268 3271 and and CC 3272 3275 the the DT 3276 3282 desire desire NN 3283 3285 to to TO 3286 3291 drive drive VB 3292 3295 him him PRP 3296 3300 away away RB 3301 3303 is be VBZ 3304 3312 scarcely scarcely RB 3313 3322 disguised disguise VBN 3322 3323 . . . 3330 3335 Ariel Ariel NNP 3336 3342 Sharon Sharon NNP 3342 3344 ’s 's POS 3345 3354 immediate immediate JJ 3355 3367 exploitation exploitation NNP 3368 3370 of of IN 3371 3374 the the DT 3375 3377 11 11 CD 3378 3387 September September NNP 3388 3397 massacres massacre NNS 3398 3400 is be VBZ 3401 3403 an an DT 3404 3416 unmistakable unmistakable JJ 3417 3421 sign sign NN 3421 3422 . . . 3423 3429 Sharon Sharon NNP 3430 3438 compared compare VBD 3439 3445 Arafat Arafat NNP 3446 3448 to to TO 3449 3452 Bin Bin NNP 3453 3458 Ladin Ladin NNP 3459 3462 and and CC 3463 3469 Mullah Mullah NNP 3470 3474 Omar Omar NNP 3475 3478 put put VBD 3479 3487 together together RB 3487 3488 . . . 3489 3493 Whom whom WP 3494 3498 does do VBZ 3499 3501 he he PRP 3502 3507 think think VB 3508 3510 he he PRP 3511 3520 resembles resemble VBZ 3520 3521 , , , 3522 3524 if if IN 3525 3528 not not RB 3529 3532 the the DT 3533 3544 perpetrator perpetrator NN 3545 3547 of of IN 3548 3551 the the DT 3552 3557 Sabra Sabra NNP 3558 3561 and and CC 3562 3569 Shatila Shatila NNP 3570 3579 massacres massacre NNS 3579 3580 ? ? . 3587 3590 How how WRB 3591 3593 to to TO 3594 3600 escape escape VB 3601 3605 from from IN 3606 3610 this this DT 3611 3620 situation situation NN 3620 3621 ? ? . 3622 3626 From from IN 3627 3630 the the DT 3631 3638 current current JJ 3639 3650 perspective perspective NN 3650 3651 , , , 3652 3657 three three CD 3658 3667 solutions solution NNS 3668 3672 seem seem VBP 3673 3674 “ `` `` 3674 3681 logical logical JJ 3681 3682 . . . 3682 3683 ” '' '' 3690 3693 The the DT 3694 3699 first first JJ 3700 3702 is be VBZ 3703 3706 the the DT 3707 3716 expulsion expulsion NN 3717 3719 of of IN 3720 3723 the the DT 3724 3736 Palestinians Palestinian NNPS 3737 3741 from from IN 3742 3746 what what WP 3747 3749 is be VBZ 3750 3755 known know VBN 3756 3758 as as IN 3759 3764 Eretz Eretz NNP 3765 3771 Israel Israel NNP 3771 3772 , , , 3773 3777 from from IN 3778 3781 all all DT 3782 3784 of of IN 3785 3794 Mandatory mandatory JJ 3795 3804 Palestine Palestine NNP 3804 3805 . . . 3806 3807 A a DT 3808 3816 recently recently RB 3817 3829 assassinated assassinate VBN 3830 3838 minister minister NN 3839 3846 favored favor VBD 3847 3851 this this DT 3852 3860 solution solution NN 3860 3861 . . . 3862 3865 Can can MD 3866 3868 we we PRP 3869 3878 seriously seriously RB 3879 3886 imagine imagine VBP 3887 3890 the the DT 3891 3897 crimes crime NNS 3898 3902 that that WDT 3903 3908 would would MD 3909 3913 have have VB 3914 3916 to to TO 3917 3919 be be VB 3920 3929 committed commit VBN 3930 3932 to to TO 3933 3940 achieve achieve VB 3941 3945 this this DT 3946 3952 result result NN 3952 3953 ? ? . 3954 3957 Can can MD 3958 3964 anyone anyone NN 3965 3972 believe believe VB 3973 3977 that that IN 3978 3981 the the DT 3982 3986 Arab arab JJ 3987 3992 world world NN 3993 3998 could could MD 3999 4006 approve approve VB 4007 4009 of of IN 4010 4012 it it PRP 4012 4013 ? ? . 4014 4018 What what WP 4019 4024 would would MD 4025 4029 then then RB 4030 4036 remain remain VB 4037 4039 of of IN 4040 4043 the the DT 4044 4053 universal universal JJ 4054 4063 character character NN 4064 4066 of of IN 4067 4070 the the DT 4071 4079 prophets prophet NNS 4080 4082 of of IN 4083 4089 Israel Israel NNP 4090 4092 – -- : 4093 4097 that that DT 4098 4100 of of IN 4101 4104 the the DT 4105 4111 second second JJ 4112 4118 Isaiah Isaiah NNP 4118 4119 , , , 4120 4123 for for IN 4124 4131 example example NN 4132 4134 – -- : 4135 4138 and and CC 4139 4141 of of IN 4142 4149 Israeli israeli JJ 4150 4158 citizens citizen NNS 4158 4159 ’ ' POS 4160 4164 hope hope NN 4165 4167 of of IN 4168 4171 one one CD 4172 4175 day day NN 4176 4182 living live VBG 4183 4185 in in IN 4186 4191 peace peace NN 4192 4194 in in IN 4195 4199 this this DT 4200 4206 region region NN 4206 4207 ? ? . 4214 4217 The the DT 4218 4223 other other JJ 4224 4232 solution solution NN 4233 4235 is be VBZ 4236 4239 the the DT 4240 4248 opposite opposite NN 4249 4251 of of IN 4252 4255 the the DT 4256 4261 first first JJ 4262 4265 one one NN 4265 4266 : : : 4267 4270 the the DT 4271 4280 departure departure NN 4281 4283 of of IN 4284 4287 the the DT 4288 4296 Israelis Israeli NNPS 4297 4299 to to TO 4300 4304 more more RBR 4305 4315 hospitable hospitable JJ 4316 4322 climes clime NNS 4322 4323 , , , 4324 4326 in in IN 4327 4330 the the DT 4331 4337 United United NNP 4338 4344 States State NNPS 4345 4347 or or CC 4348 4354 Europe Europe NNP 4354 4355 . . . 4356 4358 It it PRP 4359 4361 is be VBZ 4362 4372 absolutely absolutely RB 4373 4383 impossible impossible JJ 4384 4387 for for IN 4388 4391 the the DT 4392 4396 time time NN 4397 4402 being be VBG 4402 4403 . . . 4404 4407 But but CC 4408 4410 in in IN 4411 4414 the the DT 4415 4421 future future NN 4421 4422 ? ? . 4423 4427 What what WP 4428 4433 would would MD 4434 4440 remain remain VB 4441 4443 of of IN 4444 4447 the the DT 4448 4454 ideals ideal NNS 4455 4457 of of IN 4458 4463 those those DT 4464 4467 who who WP 4468 4471 saw see VBD 4472 4482 themselves themselves PRP 4483 4485 as as IN 4486 4491 their their PRP$ 4492 4502 liberators liberator NNS 4503 4505 of of IN 4506 4511 their their PRP$ 4512 4518 people people NNS 4519 4522 and and CC 4523 4525 as as IN 4526 4534 builders builder NNS 4534 4535 ? ? . 4536 4542 Asking ask VBG 4543 4547 this this DT 4548 4556 question question NN 4557 4559 at at IN 4560 4565 least least JJS 4566 4572 serves serve NNS 4573 4575 as as IN 4576 4577 a a DT 4578 4586 reminder reminder NN 4587 4591 that that IN 4591 4592 , , , 4593 4601 although although IN 4602 4606 many many JJ 4607 4611 have have VBP 4612 4619 already already RB 4620 4624 left leave VBN 4624 4625 , , , 4626 4633 thereby thereby RB 4634 4645 reinventing reinvente VBG 4646 4649 the the DT 4650 4658 Diaspora Diaspora NNP 4658 4659 , , , 4660 4663 the the DT 4664 4672 Israelis Israelis NNPS 4673 4677 want want VBP 4678 4680 to to TO 4681 4685 stay stay VB 4686 4689 and and CC 4690 4692 do do VB 4693 4696 not not RB 4697 4703 intend intend VB 4704 4706 to to TO 4707 4710 end end VB 4711 4713 up up RP 4714 4718 like like IN 4719 4725 French French NNP 4726 4733 Algeria Algeria NNP 4733 4734 . . . 4741 4744 The the DT 4745 4750 third third JJ 4751 4759 solution solution NN 4760 4768 consists consist VBZ 4769 4771 of of IN 4772 4783 coexistence coexistence NN 4783 4784 , , , 4785 4792 whether whether IN 4793 4795 it it PRP 4796 4801 takes take VBZ 4802 4805 the the DT 4806 4810 form form NN 4811 4813 of of IN 4814 4817 two two CD 4818 4826 separate separate JJ 4827 4833 states state NNS 4834 4836 or or CC 4837 4838 a a DT 4839 4849 federation federation NN 4850 4852 or or CC 4853 4854 a a DT 4855 4868 confederation confederation NN 4868 4869 . . . 4876 4879 Two two CD 4880 4885 basic basic JJ 4886 4896 principles principle NNS 4897 4902 could could MD 4903 4908 still still RB 4908 4909 , , , 4910 4917 perhaps perhaps RB 4917 4918 , , , 4919 4923 make make VB 4924 4926 it it PRP 4927 4935 possible possible JJ 4935 4936 . . . 4943 4946 The the DT 4947 4952 first first JJ 4953 4955 is be VBZ 4956 4960 that that DT 4961 4963 of of IN 4964 4967 not not RB 4968 4972 only only RB 4973 4978 civic civic JJ 4978 4979 , , , 4980 4983 but but CC 4984 4988 also also RB 4989 4995 social social JJ 4996 4999 and and CC 5000 5008 economic economic JJ 5008 5009 , , , 5010 5018 equality equality NN 5018 5019 . . . 5020 5024 This this DT 5025 5034 principle principle NN 5035 5042 applies apply VBZ 5043 5052 primarily primarily RB 5053 5055 to to TO 5056 5059 the the DT 5060 5069 attitudes attitude NNS 5070 5074 that that WDT 5075 5079 must must MD 5080 5087 prevail prevail VB 5088 5094 during during IN 5095 5098 any any DT 5099 5105 future future JJ 5106 5118 negotiations negotiation NNS 5118 5119 . . . 5120 5122 It it PRP 5123 5127 also also RB 5128 5135 applies apply VBZ 5136 5139 for for IN 5140 5151 Palestinian palestinian JJ 5152 5160 citizens citizen NNS 5161 5163 of of IN 5164 5170 Israel Israel NNP 5171 5174 who who WP 5174 5175 , , , 5176 5178 53 53 CD 5179 5184 years year NNS 5185 5190 after after IN 5191 5194 the the DT 5195 5203 creation creation NN 5204 5206 of of IN 5207 5210 the the DT 5211 5216 state state NN 5216 5217 , , , 5218 5221 are be VBP 5222 5227 still still RB 5228 5231 far far RB 5232 5236 from from IN 5237 5242 equal equal JJ 5242 5243 . . . 5244 5246 It it PRP 5247 5258 furthermore furthermore RB 5259 5264 holds hold VBZ 5265 5268 for for IN 5269 5272 the the DT 5273 5281 Israelis Israeli NNPS 5282 5285 who who WP 5286 5292 decide decide VBP 5293 5295 to to TO 5296 5302 remain remain VB 5303 5305 in in IN 5306 5317 Palestinian palestinian JJ 5318 5327 territory territory NN 5328 5331 and and CC 5332 5335 who who WP 5336 5340 must must MD 5341 5343 no no RB 5344 5350 longer longer RB 5351 5353 be be VB 5354 5362 encysted encyste VBN 5363 5368 there there RB 5368 5369 . . . 5376 5379 The the DT 5380 5386 second second JJ 5387 5389 is be VBZ 5390 5394 that that DT 5395 5397 of of IN 5398 5409 reciprocity reciprocity NN 5409 5410 . . . 5411 5414 Any any DT 5415 5427 renunciation renunciation NN 5428 5430 of of IN 5431 5442 sovereignty sovereignty NN 5443 5445 by by IN 5446 5452 either either DT 5453 5458 party party NN 5459 5463 must must MD 5464 5466 be be VB 5467 5478 compensated compensate VBN 5479 5481 by by IN 5482 5485 the the DT 5486 5491 other other JJ 5491 5492 . . . 5493 5497 This this DT 5498 5505 applies apply VBZ 5506 5508 to to TO 5509 5512 all all PDT 5513 5516 the the DT 5517 5525 problems problem NNS 5526 5531 under under IN 5532 5542 discussion discussion NN 5542 5543 , , , 5544 5553 including include VBG 5553 5554 , , , 5555 5557 of of IN 5558 5564 course course NN 5564 5565 , , , 5566 5569 the the DT 5570 5575 issue issue NN 5576 5578 of of IN 5579 5588 Jerusalem Jerusalem NNP 5589 5592 and and CC 5593 5595 of of IN 5596 5599 the the DT 5600 5608 refugees refugee NNS 5608 5609 . . . 5616 5618 It it PRP 5619 5623 must must MD 5624 5626 be be VB 5627 5639 acknowledged acknowledge VBN 5640 5644 that that IN 5645 5648 the the DT 5649 5659 government government NN 5660 5662 of of IN 5663 5668 Ariel Ariel NNP 5669 5675 Sharon Sharon NNP 5676 5679 has have VBZ 5680 5682 so so RB 5683 5686 far far RB 5687 5692 taken take VBN 5693 5696 the the DT 5697 5705 opposite opposite JJ 5706 5710 tack tack NN 5711 5714 and and CC 5715 5719 that that IN 5719 5720 , , , 5721 5726 while while IN 5727 5729 he he PRP 5730 5733 has have VBZ 5734 5744 grudgingly grudgingly RB 5745 5755 recognized recognize VBN 5756 5759 the the DT 5760 5772 Palestinians Palestinian NNPS 5772 5773 ’ ' POS 5774 5779 right right NN 5780 5782 to to TO 5783 5784 a a DT 5785 5790 state state NN 5790 5791 , , , 5792 5794 it it PRP 5795 5798 has have VBZ 5799 5803 been be VBN 5804 5809 under under IN 5810 5820 conditions condition NNS 5821 5825 such such JJ 5826 5830 that that IN 5831 5835 this this DT 5836 5841 state state NN 5841 5842 , , , 5843 5850 reduced reduce VBD 5851 5853 to to TO 5854 5855 a a DT 5856 5862 series series NN 5863 5865 of of IN 5866 5876 Bantustans Bantustan NNP 5876 5877 , , , 5878 5881 has have VBZ 5882 5884 no no DT 5885 5891 chance chance NN 5892 5894 of of IN 5895 5901 living live VBG 5902 5905 and and CC 5906 5916 developing develop VBG 5917 5927 peacefully peacefully RB 5927 5928 . . . 5929 5939 Extremists extremist NNS 5940 5942 on on IN 5943 5947 both both DT 5948 5953 sides side NNS 5954 5958 have have VBP 5959 5966 clearly clearly RB 5967 5977 understood understand VBN 5978 5982 this this DT 5983 5986 and and CC 5987 5991 have have VBP 5992 5999 derived derive VBN 6000 6007 nothing nothing NN 6008 6011 but but CC 6012 6025 encouragement encouragement NN 6026 6030 from from IN 6031 6033 it it PRP 6033 6034 . . . 6041 6044 The the DT 6045 6052 Israeli israeli JJ 6053 6063 ambassador ambassador NN 6064 6066 in in IN 6067 6073 France France NNP 6073 6074 , , , 6075 6079 Elie Elie NNP 6080 6087 Barnavi Barnavi NNP 6087 6088 , , , 6089 6097 recently recently RB 6098 6102 made make VBD 6103 6106 two two CD 6107 6120 contradictory contradictory JJ 6121 6131 statements statement NNS 6131 6132 : : : 6133 6137 That that IN 6138 6141 all all PDT 6142 6147 those those DT 6148 6151 who who WP 6151 6152 , , , 6153 6157 like like IN 6158 6163 Nurit Nurit NNP 6164 6169 Peled Peled NNP 6169 6170 , , , 6171 6178 believe believe VBP 6179 6183 that that IN 6184 6187 the the DT 6188 6194 Sharon Sharon NNP 6195 6205 government government NN 6206 6208 is be VBZ 6209 6210 a a DT 6211 6212 “ `` `` 6212 6222 government government NN 6223 6225 of of IN 6226 6231 death death NN 6231 6232 ” '' '' 6233 6238 could could MD 6239 6245 easily easily RB 6246 6249 fit fit VB 6250 6254 into into IN 6255 6256 a a DT 6257 6266 telephone telephone NN 6267 6272 booth booth NN 6272 6275 … ... : 6276 6279 and and CC 6280 6284 that that IN 6285 6287 by by IN 6288 6293 their their PRP$ 6294 6303 existence existence NN 6304 6308 they they PRP 6309 6319 constitute constitute VBP 6320 6326 Israel Israel NNP 6326 6328 ’s 's POS 6329 6333 very very JJ 6334 6339 honor honor NN 6339 6340 . . . 6347 6349 We we PRP 6350 6355 still still RB 6356 6360 want want VBP 6361 6363 to to TO 6364 6368 hope hope VB 6369 6373 that that IN 6374 6377 the the DT 6378 6379 “ `` `` 6379 6383 rest rest NN 6384 6386 of of IN 6387 6393 Israel Israel NNP 6393 6394 , , , 6394 6395 ” '' '' 6396 6398 as as IN 6399 6402 the the DT 6403 6411 prophets prophet NNS 6412 6418 called call VBD 6419 6421 it it PRP 6421 6422 , , , 6423 6425 is be VBZ 6426 6429 the the DT 6430 6431 “ `` `` 6431 6438 mustard mustard NN 6439 6443 seed seed NN 6443 6444 ” '' '' 6445 6452 another another DT 6453 6460 prophet prophet NN 6461 6469 referred refer VBN 6470 6472 to to TO 6472 6473 . . . 6480 6482 We we PRP 6483 6485 do do VBP 6486 6490 hope hope VB 6491 6493 so so RB 6493 6494 , , , 6495 6502 against against IN 6503 6506 all all DT 6507 6511 hope hope NN 6511 6512 . . .