2 10 Brussels Brussels NNP 11 12 - - HYPH 13 16 New New NNP 17 29 confidential confidential JJ 30 39 documents document NNS 40 48 indicate indicate VBP 49 53 that that IN 54 61 current current JJ 62 69 Israeli Israeli NNP 70 75 Prime Prime NNP 76 84 Minister Minister NNP 85 90 Ariel Ariel NNP 91 97 Sharon Sharon NNP 98 101 and and CC 102 105 the the DT 106 110 army army NN 110 112 ’s 's POS 113 119 former former JJ 120 130 leadership leadership NN 131 135 were be VBD 136 144 directly directly RB 145 156 responsible responsible JJ 157 160 for for IN 161 170 massacres massacre NNS 171 173 in in IN 174 177 the the DT 178 189 Palestinian palestinian JJ 190 197 refugee refugee NN 198 203 camps camp NNS 204 206 of of IN 207 212 Sabra Sabra NNP 213 216 and and CC 217 224 Shatila Shatila NNP 225 227 in in IN 228 232 1982 1982 CD 232 233 . . . 234 241 Lawyers lawyer NNS 242 245 for for IN 246 249 the the DT 250 259 survivors survivor NNS 259 260 , , , 261 264 who who WP 265 269 have have VBP 270 275 filed file VBN 276 277 a a DT 278 287 complaint complaint NN 288 295 against against IN 296 302 Sharon Sharon NNP 303 305 in in IN 306 313 Belgium Belgium NNP 313 314 , , , 315 319 said say VBD 320 324 this this DT 324 325 . . . 332 334 On on IN 335 341 behalf behalf NN 342 344 of of IN 345 349 some some DT 350 361 Palestinian palestinian JJ 362 371 survivors survivor NNS 371 372 , , , 373 380 lawyers lawyer NNS 381 384 Luc Luc NNP 385 392 Walleyn Walleyn NNP 393 396 and and CC 397 404 Michael Michael NNP 405 414 Verhaeghe Verhaeghe NNP 415 417 on on IN 418 420 18 18 CD 421 425 June June NNP 426 431 filed file VBD 432 433 a a DT 434 443 complaint complaint NN 444 448 with with IN 449 452 the the DT 453 461 Brussels Brussels NNP 462 468 Public Public NNP 469 480 Prosecution Prosecution NNP 481 487 Office Office NNP 488 495 against against IN 496 502 Sharon Sharon NNP 503 506 and and CC 507 512 other other JJ 513 520 Israeli israeli JJ 521 524 and and CC 525 533 Lebanese lebanese JJ 534 541 persons person NNS 542 548 deemed deem VBD 549 560 responsible responsible JJ 561 564 for for IN 565 568 the the DT 569 578 massacres massacre NNS 579 581 in in IN 582 588 Beirut Beirut NNP 588 589 . . . 596 597 A a DT 598 601 few few JJ 602 606 days day NNS 607 612 after after IN 613 619 filing file VBG 620 623 the the DT 624 633 complaint complaint NN 633 634 , , , 635 638 the the DT 639 646 lawyers lawyer NNS 647 655 received receive VBD 656 657 a a DT 658 663 stack stack NN 664 666 of of IN 667 676 documents document NNS 677 679 in in IN 680 686 Hebrew Hebrew NNP 687 690 and and CC 691 693 in in IN 694 701 English English NNP 702 711 regarding regard VBG 712 715 the the DT 716 720 1982 1982 CD 721 728 Israeli israeli JJ 729 737 invasion invasion NN 738 740 of of IN 741 748 Lebanon Lebanon NNP 749 752 and and CC 753 756 the the DT 757 762 Sabra Sabra NNP 763 766 and and CC 767 774 Shatila Shatila NNP 775 781 events event NNS 781 782 . . . 783 786 The the DT 787 796 documents document NNS 797 804 include include VBP 805 812 meeting meeting NN 813 820 reports report NNS 820 821 , , , 822 825 and and CC 826 838 intelligence intelligence NN 839 846 service service NN 847 850 and and CC 851 864 interrogation interrogation NN 865 872 reports report NNS 872 873 . . . 874 877 The the DT 878 885 lawyers lawyer NNS 886 893 refused refuse VBD 894 896 to to TO 897 903 reveal reveal VB 904 907 the the DT 908 914 source source NN 915 917 of of IN 918 921 the the DT 922 931 documents document NNS 931 932 . . . 939 946 Judging judge VBG 947 951 from from IN 952 953 a a DT 954 957 few few JJ 958 963 texts text NNS 964 968 that that IN 969 971 De De NNP 972 981 Standaard Standaard NNP 982 985 was be VBD 986 991 given give VBN 992 998 access access NN 999 1001 to to TO 1001 1002 , , , 1003 1006 the the DT 1007 1016 documents document NNS 1017 1021 seem seem VBP 1022 1024 to to TO 1025 1027 be be VB 1028 1035 related related JJ 1036 1038 to to TO 1039 1042 the the DT 1043 1050 Israeli Israeli NNP 1051 1056 Kahan Kahan NNP 1057 1067 Commission Commission NNP 1067 1068 . . . 1069 1073 This this DT 1074 1081 special special JJ 1082 1092 commission commission NN 1093 1105 investigated investigate VBD 1106 1109 the the DT 1110 1115 Sabra Sabra NNP 1116 1119 and and CC 1120 1127 Shatila Shatila NNP 1128 1134 events event NNS 1135 1137 in in IN 1138 1147 1982-1983 1982-1983 CD 1147 1148 . . . 1149 1151 It it PRP 1152 1161 published publish VBD 1162 1163 a a DT 1164 1170 report report NN 1170 1171 , , , 1172 1175 but but CC 1176 1179 not not RB 1180 1183 all all PDT 1184 1187 the the DT 1188 1197 documents document NNS 1198 1201 and and CC 1202 1215 interrogation interrogation NN 1216 1223 reports report NNS 1224 1228 were be VBD 1229 1237 released release VBN 1237 1238 , , , 1239 1246 because because IN 1247 1251 they they PRP 1252 1256 were be VBD 1257 1263 deemed deem VBN 1264 1272 damaging damage VBG 1273 1275 to to TO 1276 1279 the the DT 1280 1285 state state NN 1285 1287 ’s 's POS 1288 1297 interests interest NNS 1297 1298 . . . 1305 1312 Walleyn Walleyn NNP 1313 1316 are be VBP 1317 1326 Verhaeghe Verhaeghe NNP 1327 1330 are be VBP 1331 1340 convinced convince VBN 1341 1343 of of IN 1344 1347 the the DT 1348 1360 authenticity authenticity NN 1361 1363 of of IN 1364 1367 the the DT 1368 1377 documents document NNS 1377 1378 . . . 1379 1383 They they PRP 1384 1388 gave give VBD 1389 1392 the the DT 1393 1399 entire entire JJ 1400 1405 stack stack NN 1406 1408 to to TO 1409 1422 Investigating Investigating NNP 1423 1433 Magistrate Magistrate NNP 1434 1441 Patrick Patrick NNP 1442 1451 Collignon Collignon NNP 1451 1452 . . . 1453 1456 The the DT 1457 1464 lawyers lawyer NNS 1465 1471 expect expect VBP 1472 1476 that that IN 1477 1480 the the DT 1481 1487 Public Public NNP 1488 1499 Prosecution Prosecution NNP 1500 1506 Office Office NNP 1507 1511 will will MD 1512 1519 request request VB 1520 1526 Israel Israel NNP 1527 1529 to to TO 1530 1537 confirm confirm VB 1538 1541 the the DT 1542 1551 documents document NNS 1551 1552 ’ ' POS 1553 1565 authenticity authenticity NN 1565 1566 . . . 1573 1575 It it PRP 1576 1579 had have VBD 1580 1587 already already RB 1588 1592 been be VBN 1593 1598 known know VBN 1599 1603 that that IN 1604 1612 Lebanese lebanese JJ 1613 1623 Phalangist phalangist NN 1624 1632 militias militia NNS 1632 1633 , , , 1634 1639 which which WDT 1640 1651 perpetrated perpetrate VBD 1652 1655 the the DT 1656 1665 massacres massacre NNS 1665 1666 , , , 1667 1677 cooperated cooperate VBD 1678 1685 closely closely RB 1686 1690 with with IN 1691 1697 Israel Israel NNP 1697 1698 , , , 1699 1702 but but CC 1703 1712 according accord VBG 1713 1715 to to TO 1716 1719 the the DT 1720 1727 lawyers lawyer NNS 1727 1728 , , , 1729 1736 various various JJ 1737 1746 documents document NNS 1747 1750 now now RB 1751 1759 indicate indicate VBP 1760 1764 that that IN 1765 1771 Israel Israel NNP 1772 1775 and and CC 1776 1779 the the DT 1780 1788 Phalange Phalange NNP 1789 1792 had have VBD 1793 1800 planned plan VBN 1801 1804 the the DT 1805 1812 actions action NNS 1813 1815 in in IN 1816 1819 the the DT 1820 1825 camps camp NNS 1826 1828 in in IN 1829 1836 advance advance NN 1836 1837 , , , 1838 1842 that that IN 1843 1849 Israel Israel NNP 1850 1859 exercised exercise VBD 1860 1868 complete complete JJ 1869 1876 control control NN 1877 1881 over over IN 1882 1885 the the DT 1886 1894 militias militia NNS 1894 1895 , , , 1896 1899 and and CC 1900 1904 that that IN 1904 1905 , , , 1906 1908 in in IN 1909 1912 the the DT 1913 1917 wake wake NN 1918 1920 of of IN 1921 1924 the the DT 1925 1934 massacres massacre NNS 1934 1935 , , , 1936 1939 the the DT 1940 1947 Israeli israeli JJ 1948 1952 army army NN 1953 1963 instructed instruct VBD 1964 1967 the the DT 1968 1976 Phalange phalange NN 1977 1979 to to TO 1980 1986 assume assume VB 1987 2001 responsibility responsibility NN 2001 2002 . . . 2003 2004 “ `` `` 2004 2006 In in IN 2007 2015 practice practice NN 2015 2016 , , , 2017 2020 the the DT 2021 2031 Phalangist phalangist NN 2032 2040 militias militia NNS 2041 2049 operated operate VBD 2050 2058 directly directly RB 2059 2064 under under IN 2065 2072 Israeli israeli JJ 2073 2080 command command NN 2080 2081 . . . 2082 2088 Senior senior JJ 2089 2097 generals general NNS 2098 2101 and and CC 2102 2108 Sharon Sharon NNP 2109 2113 bore bear VBD 2114 2121 command command NN 2122 2136 responsibility responsibility NN 2137 2138 [ [ ( 2138 2147 preceding precede VBG 2148 2151 two two CD 2152 2157 words word NNS 2158 2167 published publish VBN 2168 2170 in in IN 2171 2178 English English NNP 2178 2179 ] ] ) 2180 2183 for for IN 2184 2187 the the DT 2188 2196 militias militia NNS 2196 2197 ’ ' POS 2198 2205 actions action NNS 2205 2206 . . . 2207 2216 According accord VBG 2217 2219 to to TO 2220 2227 Belgian belgian JJ 2228 2231 and and CC 2232 2245 international international JJ 2246 2254 criminal criminal JJ 2255 2258 law law NN 2258 2259 , , , 2260 2264 they they PRP 2265 2270 could could MD 2271 2273 be be VB 2274 2278 held hold VBN 2279 2290 responsible responsible JJ 2290 2291 , , , 2291 2292 ” '' '' 2293 2302 Verhaeghe Verhaeghe NNP 2303 2307 said say VBD 2307 2308 . . . 2315 2323 Tomorrow Tomorrow NNP 2323 2324 , , , 2325 2328 the the DT 2329 2336 Chamber Chamber NNP 2337 2340 for for IN 2341 2352 Indictments Indictments NNP 2353 2357 will will MD 2358 2363 begin begin VB 2364 2367 the the DT 2368 2374 debate debate NN 2375 2377 on on IN 2378 2391 Investigating Investigating NNP 2392 2397 Judge Judge NNP 2398 2407 Collignon Collignon NNP 2407 2409 ’s 's POS 2410 2419 questions question NNS 2420 2422 on on IN 2423 2426 the the DT 2427 2437 legitimacy legitimacy NN 2438 2440 of of IN 2441 2444 the the DT 2445 2449 case case NN 2450 2457 against against IN 2458 2464 Sharon Sharon NNP 2464 2465 . . . 2466 2467 A a DT 2468 2474 ruling ruling NN 2475 2477 is be VBZ 2478 2486 expected expect VBN 2487 2489 by by IN 2490 2493 the the DT 2494 2497 end end NN 2498 2500 of of IN 2501 2505 this this DT 2506 2510 year year NN 2511 2513 or or CC 2514 2519 early early JJ 2520 2524 next next JJ 2525 2529 year year NN 2529 2530 . . . 2537 2539 In in IN 2540 2543 the the DT 2544 2552 meantime meantime NN 2552 2553 , , , 2554 2557 the the DT 2558 2565 lawyers lawyer NNS 2566 2570 have have VBP 2571 2575 also also RB 2576 2585 initiated initiate VBN 2586 2587 a a DT 2588 2593 civil civil JJ 2594 2598 suit suit NN 2599 2606 against against IN 2607 2611 Elie Elie NNP 2612 2619 Hobeika Hobeika NNP 2619 2620 , , , 2621 2624 the the DT 2625 2632 militia militia NN 2633 2639 leader leader NN 2640 2643 who who WP 2644 2646 is be VBZ 2647 2655 regarded regard VBN 2656 2658 as as IN 2659 2662 one one CD 2663 2665 of of IN 2666 2669 the the DT 2670 2674 main main JJ 2675 2687 perpetrators perpetrator NNS 2688 2690 of of IN 2691 2694 the the DT 2695 2704 massacres massacre NNS 2704 2705 . . . 2706 2708 In in IN 2709 2712 the the DT 2713 2722 complaint complaint NN 2722 2723 , , , 2724 2731 Hobeika Hobeika NNP 2732 2735 had have VBD 2736 2739 not not RB 2740 2743 yet yet RB 2744 2748 been be VBN 2749 2755 called call VBN 2756 2758 by by IN 2759 2763 name name NN 2763 2764 . . . 2765 2768 The the DT 2769 2776 lawyers lawyer NNS 2777 2783 deemed deem VBD 2784 2786 it it PRP 2787 2791 wise wise JJ 2792 2794 to to TO 2795 2797 do do VB 2798 2802 this this DT 2803 2806 now now RB 2807 2814 because because IN 2815 2818 one one CD 2819 2821 of of IN 2822 2831 Collignon Collignon NNP 2831 2833 ’s 's POS 2834 2843 questions question NNS 2844 2846 is be VBZ 2847 2856 connected connect VBN 2857 2861 with with IN 2862 2865 the the DT 2866 2875 juridical juridical JJ 2876 2888 consequences consequence NNS 2889 2891 of of IN 2892 2893 a a DT 2894 2902 Lebanese lebanese JJ 2903 2910 amnesty amnesty NN 2911 2914 law law NN 2914 2915 . . .